Simon Peyton-Jones is another heavy hitter at MSR.
If F# does well, I have to wonder if a sanctioned dialect of Haskell for the CLR is in the making. The only thing giving me doubt is that I can't think up a business case for it. OCaml has an audience in the financial world which gives MS a business case for F#. Having F# already, what would an H# give them?
Who besides Jane St?
My choice of development platforms and tools doesn't mean that I'm inherently less curious about what else is available to me, and the author's generalization and yours would seem to indicate otherwise. What you're reading in the HN comments are the objections to this generalization.
If I had written this article and wrote it about how PHP developers don't know anything about unit testing, agile, JIT compilation, pre-caching, and whatever, a different audience of HN readers would be tearing it up in the comments right now.
If I was looking for a job as a .NET dev, my depth in .NET is what is important, not how well I know N number of other languages. If I'm working in a .NET stack, my experience with Java, while not worthless, is not as useful ass more depth in .NET. An individual has a finite amount of resources to spend learning about other stuff. Yes, it would be awesome if I knew tons of other languages or how things work at ever lower levels of code. I just choose to spend those resources learning things that are more immediately useful to me.
The author just took a very derogatory approach to this point and I think it's understandable that it upset people.
It's a bad thing because the MS world has traditionally been cut off from the best ideas and even the best mainstream ideas around software. When I snapped out of my dogmatic slumber as an MS dev I was shocked at how much I had been missing and how much better my work got when informed by the computing world as a whole. Although my knowledge, like most people's, is still partial and fragmented, nevertheless this was a real and very valuable state change. So I can't help but respectfully suggest that if you want to grow as a software person, you should probably seek something equivalent in your own path. It's not a question of breadth vs. depth. It's a question of a pond vs. the ocean.
The second and main point is that since this large programmer population receives its knowledge almost exclusively from MS, it's a really good thing that MS have started teaching functional programming. It's probably the best chance FP has ever had to break into the mainstream. Even if it takes over just a corner of the MS world, that corner is probably larger than the rest of FP put together. This is a really good thing, and it massively kicks the ass of the crap that MS used to feed their "Elvises" and probably still do.
I'll add a third point. We know why this is happening. It's because a little less than 15 years ago, MS changed their direction, acquired some top-notch people (starting with Hejlsberg), and started moving in a direction more informed by CS and PL theory. This process is slow, but good. One can finally see it yield real fruit in the form of F# and the recent enhancements to C#. People like Meijer are having a very real influence. Come to think of it, that's probably why people like Meijer went to MS to begin with.