Whether it's a lot or not depends entirely on how much you're making. For someone who has a $500/year side project $288 is half your revenue. For someone who has a $50,000/year side project $288 is trivial. If you're marketing to people who haven't yet launched then most of your customers are in the first group - and that makes your product sound quite expensive.
If I had the need for your product I'd be much more likely to use it if the cost was something like $1/user/month, capped at $30/month.
Secondly, I agree that it's far too much money for a weekender level. Bear in mind that most weekender projects will be using free tiers at various providers. This could easily swamp all other outgoings combined.
If you really do want to capture the weekender market I'd probably suggest cutting the cost to 1/3 of current and billing annually.
It'll be more effective marketing than anything else you could reasonably buy, and unless you have serious architectural/scaling issues shouldn't be too expensive for you.
Your license server costs $288/year. I'll need to continue using it as long as my software is in use—lets say 5 years. The service will cost me $1440 over that period.
Over that period, I'd be paying you 72% of my gross revenue.
If I only sold 100, then it would cost me $440 more than I made on licenses.
If I sold to the plan's max of 1000, your service would cost me 14% of my gross revenue ($1440 of my $10,000 gross) over that five years.
A pricing scheme that closer resembles $x/license (forever) is something I would be more interested in.
One way around this "limitation" is to store somewhere in the machine that it was activated already, and then you can cancel your service at keygen.sh. Then if you make your sales all in a single month, you only pay $24 (or roughly 1%).
Think about the time savings. If it saves you more than 10 hours of development and maintenance time, pays for itself, even if you don't have a single customer.
How many pointless purchases do we all make each month? I buy 2-3 domains per month for ideas. 90% of them just sit there.
I have 4 droplets at digital ocean just sitting there and 1 actually being used. Its the opportunity cost of losing them.
That is why God/IRS invented write-offs. If you use it, great, if not, well at least it's pre-tax!
I find that developers are especially prone to this even with salaries that are typically 50% or more higher than their national averages (500%+ in India). With all this extra disposable income, we should be spending it supporting other developers and using the tools that they make to make OUR lives easier!
But my DO droplet, which runs all my websites, costs $10/month. All the other incredible stuff I use costs 0.
Also, recurring costs add up over time. A long term commitment to a company has unknown ramifications. My income from a new project is 0.
Now that I've been forced to think about it, I probably wouldn't pay $5/month - because (as has happened to me in the past with services I relied on), the price could easily get jacked up. And then I'm committed, or have to back out some code and implementation.
Long term external commitments with companies of unproven track record and uncertain costs make me nervous.
My new plan is to see if I can solve this reasonably well myself (at much higher development costs) and only use keygen or something like it if I really have to.
Which, btw, is exactly the thought process you don't want your pricing to instigate.
I’m a weekender - building a desktop app (OS X & Win) for individuals and small businesses. I hope it turns into a real business some day, but as experience would show, it probably won’t.
On the low end, $24/month is way too much for me. I would find it offensive to pay $24/month for a licensing solution, when I pay $0 for python, flask, electron, NPM, Vue, and the myriad other technologies I rely on heavily. (Note, I don’t think it is offensive - but I feel it.)
My gut feel on pricing - don’t try to squeeze money from a stone. Give away the low end. You won’t make much money there anyway and you will almost certainly turn off many potential users and proponents. Get them hooked. Let them promote for you. Don’t let them find an alternative. Then, when they start making money, you start making money.
If I have a viable business going I will have a totally different feel on how I would see this expenditure.
2 cents for you.