News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by nickik on Sunday June 11, 2017 @01:41PM (#14532877)
Open sourcing helps everybody. Power users make sure its save for them, if it is, it is save for 'normal' users as well.

I don't need to read Signal code to have confidence in its working.

Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by FussyZeus on Sunday June 11, 2017 @01:59PM (#14532967)
OK so if your tech-inclined friend sets up a Signal server, for little to nothing in return, that's automatically more trustworthy than a multi-billion dollar corporation with an ingrained and (seemingly) solid attitude regarding NOT selling user's data?

I roll an OwnCloud server for me and my family, and I know that I'm not invading their privacy, but I could very easily do so and not leave a trace of my having done it even that a pro user could find, let alone a layman. To say that Apple is less trustworthy than a given power user solely because they use closed source is ridiculous, there is zero correlation there.

Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by Veratyr on Sunday June 11, 2017 @03:17PM (#14533299)
> Power users make sure its save for them, if it is, it is save for 'normal' users as well.

Power users can make sure the code they're running is safe for them. There's no guarantee that Signal for example is running the same code they release to others.

Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by lorenzhs on Sunday June 11, 2017 @04:27PM (#14533606)
Signal for Android has reproducible builds, so you can verify that the version on the Play Store matches the code you audited.
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by krallja on Sunday June 11, 2017 @05:19PM (#14533843)
How does that help you verify what is running on the server?
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by smichel17 on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:39AM (#14536797)
The whole point of e2e is that you don't have to trust the server (for content; you do have to trust that they aren't saving metadata).
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by nickpsecurity on Sunday June 11, 2017 @06:12PM (#14534081)
They can use trusted computing or HSM tech for that. They have the money but probably won't spend it.
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by threeseed on Sunday June 11, 2017 @07:59PM (#14534476)
None of that addresses the point. Without third party, independent verification of their servers and the code that is running open source provides limited (if any) improvements to privacy and security.
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by nickpsecurity on Sunday June 11, 2017 @10:54PM (#14534974)
That's part of the point rather than separate. A closed system without any way to prove it's running something often can't to get 3rd party verification or user trust that's consistently believable. An open-source, tamper-resistant system can. Quite a bit of difference. Once verifications come in, the effects of reputation then allow users with less technical knowledge to learn what's trustworthy or not.
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by closeparen on Sunday June 11, 2017 @06:37PM (#14534187)
But they don't, so why do they get points for having an open source server?
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by nickpsecurity on Sunday June 11, 2017 @07:54PM (#14534457)
For a full solution, it would be a start to what they needed. The main benefit of an open-source server is that people can audit it for vulnerabilities. As in, they get free to cheap labor to reduce their liabilities. People might also submit extensions they find useful. The usual benefits of FOSS for suppliers.
Re:Apple Is Trying to Make iMessages More Private by bilbo0s on Sunday June 11, 2017 @01:52PM (#14532934)
"...if it is, it is save for 'normal' users as well..."

Not sure about that. I think even if a power user were to say "this is safe", you still have a boatload of integrity problems with the software.

-How do we know the power users can be trusted?

-Even if they can, what guarantee do we have that the service provider we use is using the same open source code that the power user validated?

-Etc, etc, etc. Basically, a lot of trust issues.

I agree with asadlionpk, open source can generally only be proven to help power users in a trustless environment. And where security is concerned, we cannot ascribe the "safe" attribute to any system where that safety cannot be proven.