News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by rcdmd on Saturday June 10, 2017 @11:07PM (#14530400)
Unfortunately, drug companies have few economic incentives to develop novel antibiotics given the immense costs/risks of human trials and the minimal expected monetary reward. Clinicians reserve the "big gun" antibiotics for the rare cases that need them-- which reduces the cash drug companies get from pushing them through clinical trials.

Compared to other drugs, antibiotics are relatively easy and cheap to discover or "invent" with modern techniques. Getting them through clinical trials, on the other hand, is not cheap.

Many clinicians should be less loose with antibiotics, sure. But, that won't eliminate resistance. Realistically, when superbugs become common, the incentives pharmaceutical companies face will shift. It's just there will be a lot of morbidity and mortality while we're waiting for their drugs to make it to hospital pharmacies.

Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by refurb on Sunday June 11, 2017 @02:04AM (#14530874)
antibiotics are relatively easy and cheap to discover or "invent" with modern techniques

As someone who used to do antibiotic R&D I strongly disagree with statement. Making a drug that kills bacteria but not the host is really damn hard.

Your point about the economic incentives is very true.

Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by autokad on Sunday June 11, 2017 @07:39AM (#14531579)
yeah, I think the article said a new one hasn't been invented in 30 years or so
Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by FooBarWidget on Sunday June 11, 2017 @02:13AM (#14530897)
> Clinicians reserve the "big gun" antibiotics for the rare cases that need them-- which reduces the cash drug companies get from pushing them through clinical trials.

This statement seems to directly contradict what the article says:

"According to Sprenger, “there are no legal instruments to prohibit the use of a new antibiotic.” What that means is if a new antibiotic is released there’s no way to stop the world from overusing it. At current usage levels a new antibiotic, he says, would only have about two years on the market before bacterial resistance to it develops."

If the world overuses a new antibiotic then the pharma company should be swimming in cash. And if the pharma company isn't swimming in cash because people reserve them for rare cases, then it should not be possible for the world to overuse the new antibiotic.

Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by candiodari on Saturday June 10, 2017 @11:43PM (#14530498)
Sounds like the solution is to have a very effective, very expensive antibiotic.
Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by danieltillett on Sunday June 11, 2017 @07:10AM (#14531521)
That would work if you could prevent companies in China and India just making it and selling it. The problem right now is this is what happens to each new "last line of defence" antibiotic - by the time it gets used in the west it has been in high use in other countries and resistance is wide spread.
Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by xherberta on Saturday June 10, 2017 @11:55PM (#14530525)
I don't know. With the third-party payer system, cost is hardly a factor in medical decisions.
Re:How we can stop antibiotic resistance by epmaybe on Sunday June 11, 2017 @09:34AM (#14531894)
Is it not? I was under the impression that as providers we should provide affordable care as well. For example, theres no reason to throw every test at a patient that has clear signs of a certain bacterial infection.

Maybe cost is less of a factor in life threatening situations.