Re:Ask HN: Why is Stripe's 'Remember Me' considered secure? ...
by prostoalex on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:53PM
(#14517114)
> although admittedly you would have to intercept the text message code
This is the key. Unless you are the mobile operator or a government entity, your only other options are fake cell phone towers, i.e. stingrays, which are monopolized by government, or incredible circumstantial luck (the user happens to use a virtual phone number for texting, so SMS is going over WiFi, and you have man-in-the-middled the router). I guess you could also root user's phone or gain access to Stripe's/Lyft's infrastructure, but then the question of intercepting a confirmation SMS wouldn't pop up.
The next level for either of those services is to support message-less second-factor auth (Authy, Google Authenticator, Microsoft Authenticator).
This is the key. Unless you are the mobile operator or a government entity, your only other options are fake cell phone towers, i.e. stingrays, which are monopolized by government, or incredible circumstantial luck (the user happens to use a virtual phone number for texting, so SMS is going over WiFi, and you have man-in-the-middled the router). I guess you could also root user's phone or gain access to Stripe's/Lyft's infrastructure, but then the question of intercepting a confirmation SMS wouldn't pop up.
The next level for either of those services is to support message-less second-factor auth (Authy, Google Authenticator, Microsoft Authenticator).