News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by spiderfarmer on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:26PM (#14516043)
What can Google do in the cloud that Apple can't do on the device?
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by kingbirdy on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:30PM (#14516065)
Apple can only look at you to learn - Google can look at you, and a million other people like you
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by jug on Thursday June 08, 2017 @03:11PM (#14516377)
I think many Apple users would be happy if only Siri could answer factual questions objectively and follow a conversation, being happy with a minimum of privacy collection like current location, name of spouse for messaging, etc.

While some may prefer a knowledge about you or you via people like you, as in, "Please recommend me a great movie", Siri is currently not in a stage where she may tell you stuff like "How do I mix a White Russian?" Google Assistant give me 6 steps with a photo and a follow up question "What about Screwdriver?" Siri gets utterly wrecked in the knowledge based questions.

I think the main problem is not privacy-related, but knowledge base-related. Google is building upon a fricking huge search engine via a knowledge graph and the sky is the limit for how well an AI can do. Apple is building on what, a shut down Ping social network, Apple Music listening habits, Wolfram Alpha hopes if all else fails, and a sparse Bing Search API if that failed too?

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by naravara on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:49PM (#14517083)
>While some may prefer a knowledge about you or you via people like you, as in, "Please recommend me a great movie". . .

Not to mention that Apple positioned itself as a brand for people who "Think Different." I don't think people who got taken in by that messaging would be attracted to the prospect of services that can more efficiently pigeonhole them.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by naravara on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:37PM (#14516123)
I thought Apple figured out a way to create unique IDs and profiles that can't be traced back to the individual person? So they can still find people like you for analytical purposes to tune their models.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by sheeshkebab on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:30PM (#14516069)
Probably can't get all the metrics and data needed to actually tune/make it work.

I periodically delete all my history from google servers, thanks to their privacy tool, and google gets just a dumb for me as siri.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by Eridrus on Friday June 09, 2017 @10:11AM (#14521466)
Speech recognition and natural language understanding.

If you watched the HomePod reveal you'd know that it sends your speech to the cloud for understanding. Which seems like a pretty clear admission that this can't all be done on-device easily.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by dr1337 on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:30PM (#14516067)
The simplest example would be speech recognition. With the exception of Keyword Spotting Systems like Hey Siri or OK Google, it's currently practically impossible to implement larger vocabulary speech recognition on device.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by gervase on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:13PM (#14516871)
Google will happily permit you to download trained models of <100MB to your phone via Google Translate, which permit not only offline vocabulary recognition of a remarkably wide range, but will also then translate that input into another language (also offline).

I believe the restrictions imposed by keyword-spotting have more to do with the always-listening and/or power-efficient nature of the task, rather than the restrictions on the legibility of offline speech recognition.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by dragonwriter on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:40PM (#14516139)
I'm pretty sure larger vocabulary local speech recognition on devices with less computing power than modern smartphones has existed (products for continuous speech recognition on PC go back to at least Dragon Naturally Speaking in 1997.)