Re:Optimizing things in the USSR (2016)
by kodfodrasz on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:31PM
(#14516081)
Actually the central planners did plan backups and alternatives for everything. With all its flaws even the SU was not so flawed to let total idiots make every economic decision.
Just think of Mig and Sukhoi, for a simple example. Or NPO-Saturn and Tumansky, if you prefer jet-engine manufacturers.
> not so flawed to let total idiots make every economic decision
You might want to read up on Khruschev's corn farming plans, Gorbachev's prohibition, Mao's backyard furnaces and many more. Slightly tangent, check on Trofim Lysenko's anti-genetics antics. USSR style socialism explicitly declared ideology over science, engineering and what not. And by ideology they meant whatever The Great Leader says.
I guess the equivalent for nations could exist, but it would require free migration. USSR central planning screw up? Guess it's time to emigrate to China. Of course switching the nation you are part of is usually (but not always) more complicated than switching the product you buy.
Re:Optimizing things in the USSR (2016)
by antisthenes on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:37PM
(#14516120)
Have you read the actual article? It explains in detail why it didn't do as well, namely computational complexity (essentially solved today), and the general non-adoption of ideas.
There's no reason to believe it wouldn't be viable today.
And if GE, say, messes us on jet engines, well, there's always Rolls-Royce. If the central planners mess up, you don't have an alternative.