If you make it largely a private exercise, you could have more countries involved while avoiding some or most of the political overhead (eg Chinese engineers as opposed to the Chinese national space program).
Also, if the cost (and the perceived cost) could be lowered, I don't think there would be much popular resistance.
I agree with Buzz that we should germinate Mars as a genetic failsafe. I'm sure there are many possible planet-killing events whose effects would pass in time (giant asteroid for one) allowing the Earth to be repopulated.
http://nextbigfuture.com/2009/10/nuclear-weapon-issues-are-i...
But there was a recent story on here that a single reasonably sized asteroid would net about $1 Trillion worth of materials. It seems like a very profitable exercise.
I did find this interesting article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asteroid_mining
I think the primary missing piece is the national drive to get to Mars. The moon-landing worked so well (and used an enormous portion of GDP, even as the US ramped up action in Vietnam) because the country was unquestionably committed to landing on the moon. Part of that, of course, was JFK's charisma in selling it, and his legacy post-Dallas. I don't get that there's the same commitment to Mars.
Now, if it were a global commitment (likely NATO, maybe some Chinese involvement, but we'd call it global) then it could work. But that's a discussion for a President and international community in good times - when Greece is going bankrupt and 10% of the US is unemployed, few at home, in Europe or internationally are going to jump behind a Mars vision.