https://www.stavros.io/posts/holy-grail-backups/
I have posted it to maybe help a few people who want to do backups: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14507656
Are you using rsync.net's "hidden" attic/borg option? This makes the price very attractive.
You mention using "attic check" to guard against bitrot on the provider's storage. How is this in terms of bandwidth used? Does it have to transfer every byte or does it compute a checksum on the encrypted data (since rsync.net doesn't have the raw data) and just send that?
I am, yes, and it is quite attractive.
> You mention using "attic check" to guard against bitrot on the provider's storage. How is this in terms of bandwidth used? Does it have to transfer every byte or does it compute a checksum on the encrypted data (since rsync.net doesn't have the raw data) and just send that?
It's very bandwidth-efficient, but I have stopped doing that every day, as rsync.net told me they use ZFS and scrub their arrays regularly, so they would discover bit rot early. I only run the check once a month now.
Generally speaking, attic has at least one data corruption bug fixed in Borg that make it unsafe to use with remote repositories unless the SSH connection is 100% stable. Attic also has another similar bug that corrupts the created archive when it encounters an I/O error in the repository.
There is a "Migrating from Attic" "sales pitch" (if you like) in the beta docs (-- switch versions in the lower left corner for stable docs): http://borgbackup.readthedocs.io/en/latest/faq.html#migratin...
[1] and of course checksumming and error correction of the file system, if any. Since rsync.net is ZFS the --repository-only check is a stronger than on a plain old file system with no checksums.
It would be a case of multiple machines each backing up their /etc, /home, /var, etc to one place.
A quick Google search gives me the feeling that it runs under FreeBSD's Linux emulation and the port seems to break occasionally. I could run it on a real Linux in a VM on FreeBSD though, so that's a potential option.
(Disclosure: I'm a paying customer of CrashPlan, but otherwise have no connection with the service.)
- Off-site storage, preferably not costing too much.
- Option for on-site storage (e.g., to store a backup "in the cloud" and on my NAS)
- Keeps version history, with the associated goodies (purging old backups, etc)
- Able to run on FreeBSD and Linux, with Windows and MacOS being nice to have but not required.
- Able to back up multiple machines to one account.
I strongly suspect that my solution will involve two separate things - one to actually do the backups and another for the storage.
So far, not having looked at Duplicacy, I'm leaning strongly towards attic/borg with rsync.net for off-site storage. At first glance, Duplicacy looks like it will meet my requirements so I will have to give it a closer look before I pick a solution.