News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Five years of IPv6: whither the next five? by throwaway2048 on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @01:39AM (#14503984)
Mutilevel NAT is a hell of a lot harder to troubleshoot than some extra address bits.
Re:Five years of IPv6: whither the next five? by ra1n85 on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @05:19AM (#14504759)
Why would you use multilevel NAT? That sounds like design sadness.
Re:Five years of IPv6: whither the next five? by belorn on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @06:24AM (#14505017)
You can very easy end up with multilevel nat. The last mile (ie a apartment complex) can have one and then the customer router is the second.

But that assumes that the ISP has addresses to spare. If not, we have the three layers of nat. ISP->apartment complex->customer router->all customer devices.

And then we have intermediates, like ISP->municipal->apartment complex->customer router->customer devices. Now we have four layers of nat.

In the really worse case, ISP are split up into multiple ones, and you can get carrier grade NAT in the form of ISP->ISP->municipal->apartment complex->customer router->customer devices. Five layers of nat and up.

Multilevel NAT is a form of sadness that NAT never was designed to do.

Re:Five years of IPv6: whither the next five? by zkms on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @04:51PM (#14509763)
NAT is also expensive to operate at the scale and reliability that large network operators need. If stateful NAT middleboxes go down, everything goes down -- it's a point of failure that's hard to route around!

Also there's the issue that you'll end up having multiple devices with the same RFC1918 addresses, which is an immense pain in the arse to deal with.