Re:Scientists Pit Sourdough Against White Bread
by piva00 on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @08:13AM
(#14505613)
Microbiome is becoming the scapegoat for some studies when they can't find a root cause, is it REALLY that important or are we just seeing things our models failed at pushed to some little understood part of dietary science?
I've seen the microbiome argument used as an explanation for weight loss, carbs processing, fat processing, protein absorption and now this, it's just feeling too much of our failed model relying on this unknown territory.
Re:Scientists Pit Sourdough Against White Bread
by abcanthur on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @12:29AM
(#14503766)
The journalists do include two very frank quotations from peers criticizing the experiment and what conclusions could be drawn. So annoying headline maybe, but honestly reported.
And in this topic the no-story, no-effect is the story. Perhaps artisanal sourdough is mostly similar to white bread, and the range of different glycemic responses gets subsumed by differences in individual responses to any generic bread. Artisanal bread and wonderbread, equally bad, equally good.
Re:Scientists Pit Sourdough Against White Bread
by epistasis on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @12:13AM
(#14503708)
Sounds like the title served its purpose perfectly. Annoying and effective.
Re:Scientists Pit Sourdough Against White Bread
by nhebb on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @12:14AM
(#14503713)
Plus, other researchers are skeptical of the results due to the low sample size (n = 20).
Re:Scientists Pit Sourdough Against White Bread
by AstralStorm on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @03:21AM
(#14504308)
It exposes the high amount of variability in even simple nutritional experiments. At least it is honest.
Unlike some research that suggest x is good by testing on similarly small samples.
If I'd known that was the result I wouldn't have clicked through. The title is fucking idiotic.