News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pi is Wrong by btilly on Monday June 21, 2010 @05:34PM (#1450147)
Old news. This ranks up there with the fact that it was a bad idea to use base 10 instead of base 12. Absolutely and utterly true, but completely not worth the switching costs.
Re:Pi is Wrong by jessriedel on Monday June 21, 2010 @05:49PM (#1450183)
It's still important for everyone doing math to know that the convention is bad, though, even if it's not worth switching. Then it becomes clear in several instances that slight blemishes in the beauty of equations are of human origin. It also help you think of 2pi as an object.
Re:Pi is Wrong by BahUnfair on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @04:50AM (#1451324)
Teaching this in the classroom could engage a lot of students that might otherwise be bored sh*tless of the regular curriculum. For those that do pay attention it could open their minds to a new way of looking at maths as a human tool rather than some universal law. It's a shame its taken me till freshman year and reading this article to make the connection that a 6th of a radian is a third of one quadrant. I can't imagine how much simpler this would have been to learn if it was 2pi.
Re:Pi is Wrong by jacobolus on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @12:04AM (#1450898)
> not worth the switching costs.

Well, it’s certainly too hard to practically switch, and so we won’t. But that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s not worth the cost. We’ve apparently had π in its current form for for 300 years; we’re going to have to live with it much longer than that.

The way to actually make a change like that though, assuming we wanted to, would be to just make up a new symbol for 2π, and start using it. For a while, the two symbols would coexist, and then someday the π symbol would just start to fade out.

(Probably about as easy to change in practice as switching to metric dates and times, as the French tried to do after the revolution.)

Re:Pi is Wrong by axod on Monday June 21, 2010 @07:03PM (#1450371)
It's still important for those studying mathematics to realize that things like this are completely arbitrary.

I remember the moment as a kid when I realized that the number 10 wasn't some magical number, but just some arbitrary number we've decided to use as a base. Definitely a stupid choice IMHO, but it's what we're stuck with.

Re:Pi is Wrong by rbranson on Monday June 21, 2010 @11:42PM (#1450856)
Base 10 isn't arbitrary. It's believed that it's based on the human condition of having 10 fingers.
Re:Pi is Wrong by loup-vaillant on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @03:41AM (#1451231)
And we have 12 non-thumb phalanxes on each hand. Point each phalanx of one hand with your thumb (of the same hand), and you can count up to 12. With 5 fingers on the other hand, you can count 5 dozen: 60.

Base 10 may not be completely arbitrary, but is is undoubtedly lazy.

Re:Pi is Wrong by axod on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @02:59AM (#1451184)
8 fingers + 2 thumbs.

It would have actually been more useful to use 8 fingers = octal.

But then who counts with their fingers these days?

Re:Pi is Wrong by NickPollard on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @05:33AM (#1451384)
Count in binary and you can count to 1023 on your hands.

(2^10 - 1 : you have 10 digits on your hands. This also assumes you have a value for 0.)

Re:Pi is Wrong by Natsu on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @07:04AM (#1451513)
When demonstrating that to others, be wary of counting as a demonstration. It might make be memorable, but people can get upset when you get to the number 4.

Sadly, I know this from experience.

Re:Pi is Wrong by adbge on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @03:00AM (#1451188)
Base 10 is arbitrary in the sense that it is "based on or determined by individual preference or convenience rather than by necessity or the intrinsic nature of something."

However, if you bother thinking about the word arbitrary too hard (as your comment inspired me to do), you end up in the realm of existentialism and down the proverbial rabbit hole.

Re:Pi is Wrong by cwp on Monday June 21, 2010 @06:20PM (#1450282)
Can you provide a reference for this? I'd like to know the reasoning.
Re:Pi is Wrong by btilly on Monday June 21, 2010 @07:11PM (#1450383)
The reasoning is that when we divide something evenly, we usually want to divide it into a small number of parts. 12 divides evenly into small parts better than 10 does, and so more often provides a convenient division.

For instance if we assume that half the time we need to divide into halves, 1/4 of the time into thirds, 1/8 into quarters and so on, then over 90% of the time you wish to split something into 1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/6 or 1/12. All of which are trivial in a duodecimal system. By contrast only 56% of the time do you wish to split into the similarly easy 1/2, 1/5 or 1/10 in decimal. Even if we say that 1/4 and 1/8 are OK in decimal, we still wind up with inconvenient repeating fractions over 3 times as often as duodecimals do.

Re:Pi is Wrong by Dove on Monday June 21, 2010 @09:36PM (#1450630)
This seemed pedantic and silly to me until I read the reasoning in the wikipedia article. After all, we use numbers to do far more things than division, don't we?

However, I was impressed by the far-reaching implications of this fact. The regularity of the base 12 times table was particularly compelling. You know how easy the 2's and 5's row is to learn on the times table, right? There's an obvious pattern that's easy to memorize? Lots of numbers are like that in base 12.

Re:Pi is Wrong by petewarden on Monday June 21, 2010 @08:40PM (#1450533)
A slight tangent, but I recently ran across a fascinating theory on the origin of base-12 systems. If you use your thumb as a marker, you can touch four finger joints on each hand for a total of 12 positions. I tried it and it's a surprisingly natural way of keeping count. Here's the source paper:

http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/~history/HistTopics/Babyl...

Re:Pi is Wrong by Dove on Monday June 21, 2010 @10:11PM (#1450681)
Hmm. That is a very natural way to count quite high on your fingers.

But it seems unlikely as the origin of the Babylonian system cited. The 60 symbols are written in base 10; if it grew out of a culture that counted to twelve on their fingers, I'd expect to see five groups of twelve, not six groups of ten.

I can think of a more natural explanation. When I am counting something on my fingers (in the conventional way), I often want a way to store the tens digit. Perhaps the Babylonians did, too. That the tens digit is drawn as two groups of three is suggestive that whatever method they used stored a trinary and a binary state.

So, when I count off (palms up), I get to ten on the thumb of my right hand. It has a little more dexterity than my other fingers and can store more states. It's pretty straightforward to get to six by leaving it bent/straight and pointing out/up/in. It's natural to do while counting, too. (Bent and pointing in is a little uncomfortable if I want to use the other fingers, but then . . . you don't ever need to actually store 'six').

Re:Pi is Wrong by caf on Monday June 21, 2010 @09:06PM (#1450580)
If you use the tip of each finger as well, you can count in hex to 0xff with two hands ;)
Re:Pi is Wrong by what on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @12:58PM (#1452414)
You can count to 1023 in binary using both hands.
Re:Pi is Wrong by eitally on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @12:54PM (#1452405)
Anecdotal evidence of real life application: my mother (Indian/Pakistani, born in the '40s) counts this way. I never asked, but presumably she was either taught by her parents or in school.
Re:Pi is Wrong by kinghajj on Monday June 21, 2010 @06:35PM (#1450311)
The Wikipedia article on duodecimal should give enough reasoning.
Re:Pi is Wrong by sb on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @04:22AM (#1451284)
I have not thought about it, but wouldn't we lose the positional characteristic that base-10 offers if we switched to base-12?
Re:Pi is Wrong by sid0 on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @04:25AM (#1451289)
Of course not. All base-N number systems are by definition positional.