News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Monday March 24, 2008 @04:13PM (#144948)
Of course there is something you could do. People aren't static. So what if the people who like you came here, and the ones who didn't stayed there? If you say good enough things everyone will like you and it will be a mute point.

Sure it's harder because there is some initial negative reaction to overcome from the reddit group. And it may not be the best use of your time. But it could be done with sufficient skill.

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by gruseom on Monday March 24, 2008 @06:07PM (#145071)
If you say good enough things everyone will like you

Oh my goodness. You're not serious, are you? This is a strategy for obtaining misery and contempt... and deserving it!

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Monday March 24, 2008 @06:19PM (#145087)
I am serious. What do you think could possibly prevent this from working (other than insufficient skill to say good enough things)?

You say it's a strategy for obtaining misery and contempt. But it's not a strategy. It's just a fact. The strategy of attempting to get everyone to like you in this way is something different. That's hard and I didn't recommend it, I only said it is possible.

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by DougBTX on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @07:25AM (#145598)
> What do you think could possibly prevent this from working?

One possibility springs to mind. What if someone was to comment on an article by PG, but without reading the article itself? Someone could say bad things about you without listening to what you have to say, you'd have no chance to change their mind.

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @01:35PM (#145878)
Heh. Well if it's good enough then word will get around. One day all his friends will have read it, loved it, and told him to read it. Plus it would be all over TV and radio and culture in general, so it'd be hard to have a normal conversation while missing all the references to it.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by gruseom on Monday March 24, 2008 @07:32PM (#145156)
What do you think could possibly prevent this from working

The people you're trying to please have contradictory opinions and desires. What you say to please Group A will strike Group B as an outrage! And if you try to remove everything potentially offensive to anybody, well, that will turn you into such a pandering namby-pamb that the whole world will find you annoying and want to poke you with a stick.

Edit: Just to be clear, I'm not saying one should go around offending people. I'm saying that trying to get everyone to like you is hopeless and that effort put into doing so will both warp and weaken you.

Other edit: just noticed that pchristensen already made the same point.

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Monday March 24, 2008 @07:46PM (#145181)
Pleasing two groups that start with contradictory opinions requires persuading at least one group to change it's mind. That's definitely possible because if they contradict then at least one of them is mistaken and would benefit from changing its mind.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by 0x44 on Monday March 24, 2008 @11:40PM (#145401)
Let's assume there exist two groups of people. The members of group A think that some improved product is better because it tastes great. The members of group B, on the other hand, believe that the same product is better because it's now less filling. Keeping in mind that the product is better because it both tastes great, and is less filling. Which group is mistaken? Which group would benefit from changing their minds?
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @12:44AM (#145438)
Their ideas don't really contradict. But they think they do because, apparently, both sides have the mistaken view that a product has to be better for exactly one reason.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by 0x44 on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @08:07AM (#145617)
My example was obviously a gross simplification, but not all disagreement stems from contradiction. Worse, sometimes when people agree on many points they are in inreconcilable disagreement with each other on others. If we were to consider that both groups have held their position for many years, it should be immediately apparent that it would be impossible for either to change their mind. Time calcifies opinion.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @01:03PM (#145851)
You are using the word "impossible" to mean "very hard", and I am not.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by 0x44 on Wednesday March 26, 2008 @08:41AM (#146807)
You're right, though I think I would say "extremely difficult, tending toward impossible". People do not change their minds easily, especially on subjects they feel a strong emotional attachment to.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by pchristensen on Monday March 24, 2008 @07:04PM (#145134)
This assumes that there are no two people in a community with opposite viewpoints. If someone has the opposite viewpoint of you and you start writing stuff to please them, then they'll just hate you for pandering. Plus, the people that agreed with you will call you a traitor and a sellout. Fun times!
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Monday March 24, 2008 @07:29PM (#145153)
My premise is more that there is a truth of the matter. Even if people start with opposite view points, that won't last when sufficiently good/true things are said (plus enough help seeing why this new view is better, and how to change, and how that will improve their life, etc).
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by gruseom on Monday March 24, 2008 @07:38PM (#145164)
You're assuming that people want to hear the truth. That is not at all what most people want. And if you insist on offering it to them against their desires they will eat you like (dare I say) a caged lion. :)
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Monday March 24, 2008 @07:44PM (#145172)
They might not want the truth now, but they could be shown why it's good to want it, and shown how much nicer that lifestyle is, and helped to change. Hard but certainly possible.
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by brzozan on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @12:50PM (#145838)
This lifestyle is nicer FOR YOU. Not necessarily FOR THEM.

If I like spinach and you don't, how will you show me, that not eating spinach is nicer? Or the other way around?

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @01:06PM (#145854)
There are exist some truths about what lifestyles are nice for everyone. If they violate some of those, then changing would benefit them.

As far as we know, the truth about eating is a lot more like "eat foods you like" than "eat foods X, Y, and Z but not A, B, or C". So we can all agree that I will eat spinach because I like it, and you won't because you don't. That doesn't contradict, and is no reason for disagreement.

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by brzozan on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @01:17PM (#145860)
The only truths about lifestyles true for everyone I can come up with is "don't hit yourself with a hammer" and "don't eat poison". Definitely not "work for yourself" or "work for corp". A lot of people is unhappy working for corp, but a lot likes it better than being on their own (me included).

It's exactly the same way as with food - "work where you like".

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @01:26PM (#145873)
Hold on there, I didn't say anything about people should work for themselves. We can do better than "don't hit yourself with a hammer", but nothing like "everyone should work for themselves" (that'd be a bit hard with no possibility of hiring employees, lol).
Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by brzozan on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @01:43PM (#145892)
Oops, sorry. I did stretch it a bit :)

The flame with Paul started with him drawing conclusion (or leaving such impression) that natural state for human is to be own boss and that ones that work for somebody are missing something in life (hence their life is somehow inferior). That's why I jumped to "work" topic. You did not mention work, but I connected Paul's essay with your post.

My point was that IMO there are very few universal truths about life and they are limited to very basic things. Differences between particular human beings and environments they live in are too big to draw general conclusions.

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @01:50PM (#145899)
Right, I see. But I think there are actually a lot of universal truths.

For example, lifestyles that are open to criticism are more successful because they correct more of their errors. Lifestyles with appropriate attention to detail are more successful too (that doesn't mean more attention to detail, it means being good at judging the right amount for the situation and using that. And there exist non-obvious truths about how to judge the appropriate amount of detail for a situation).

And there's all that stuff we call "scientific rigor" or the scientific method. While it's normally associated with only science, large parts of it are valuable to thinking in general. And better ways of thinking definitely make for a better life.

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by brzozan on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @04:13PM (#146072)
I think we got common ground :) I consider features like "being open to criticism" and "appropriate level of attention to detail" basic things, so it does not contradict my POV (general conclusions limited to basic stuff), and since it is you who wrote it I assume, that it complies with yours too.

Not sure about how scientific method applies here (I DO agree with scientific method though), but I can live with that.

Now we just have to use it to somehow extinguish original flame of "you were not meant to ..." :) Just kidding. I'm happy with discussion getting to the point of common ground +- epsilon.

I'll drink to that!

EDIT: how one downvotes posts here (no, not this thread)? I see only up arrows :|

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @04:20PM (#146080)
Yay.

You need more karma to be able to vote down. 20 or 25 or so.

The reason I'd say those aren't basic things is they (and many others) are, apparently, too hard for most people. The world could be greatly improved by people doing them better. (Not to say I do all of them perfectly, either.)

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by brzozan on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @05:01PM (#146135)
Thanks.

<friendly troll> That voting thing does not sound fair. Or the other way - seems aimed at putting some bias. "Only those that agree with majority can vote against" stuff.

Like in communist countries (hey, I live in a former one): only ones that agree with the Party can vote against it. </friendly troll>

Re:Everything's Blub All Over Again by xlnt on Tuesday March 25, 2008 @06:01PM (#146210)
25 karma is really not very much, even for someone who's consistently in the minority, I think the point is not to let totally new accounts use downvote.