News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by kibwen on Monday June 05, 2017 @03:47PM (#14490921)
But Google already does do this, in ways that I found surprising. After buying a long-distance bus ticket last week, which emailed a confirmation message to my Gmail address, I later went into Google Maps and found that it had highlighted the bus station on the local map and placed the time of my bus' departure beside it. I believe it does this same sort of thing with calendar events as well (both in implicitly creating calendar events based on scraping emails, and in creating map highlights based on events you've explicitly created). Convenient no doubt, but I'm not sure I want many more implicit interactions between the apps in Google's ecosystem.

EDIT: Here's another one: after taking photos using the camera app (Android phone), Google Maps later pops up a system notification asking me to upload my photos to the location page of whatever establishment I appeared to be in at the time (bar, park, nightclub, etc.). Frankly, I'm frustrated that I can't find a setting to disable these unwelcome prompts without turning off Maps notifications entirely.

EDIT 2: I suppose I should clarify that I do travel a lot, and the specific feature described in the OP--suggesting things to do based upon inferring your status as an out-of-towner--sounds very useful. But I'd definitely only want it as an opt-in feature, not opt-out.

Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by kornakiewicz on Monday June 05, 2017 @05:17PM (#14492170)
Speaking about requests to upload photos to Google Maps. I live in historic and very touristic area of Barcelona. For some reason, the building I live in is a thing in Google Maps. So, very often when I take a photo in my flat, Google encourage me to share it and I don't feel well thinking about a possibility that one of my selfies will end up Google Maps, promoting a tenement from XIX century.
[dead]
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by killjoywashere on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:27PM (#14493682)
Sometimes we think things that, what relevant and accurate, are better left unsaid, simply because they reflect more negatively on us than the other.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by elefanten on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:56PM (#14493851)
Or, you know, it could be a cultural difference and not a sign of anything negative.

*Not saying you precluded that. Just adding another reason to have a higher threshold for being rude.

Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by squeaky-clean on Monday June 05, 2017 @04:36PM (#14491673)
Likewise, with the traveling example, Google always tells me when my flight is and when I should leave for the airport on that day.

The info is also kept up to date in pretty much real time. MIA has a habit of moving flights to a different gate about 4 hours before or so. So if I check-in online the night before and get my boarding pass, the gate on my pass is usually not the correct gate anymore in the morning. I sign up for the AA text alerts, and have never ever received a text that my gate was changed, but the Google notification always works.

Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by techstrategist on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @02:08AM (#14495133)
Google doesn't seem to understand airport security in my case. I typically get a "leave now to arrive on time" notification while sitting at the gate.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by ajford on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @03:48PM (#14500623)
Yeah, I wish the advanced time was configurable. It was more of an issue when I was living in Puerto Rico, but getting through security at that airport would often take much longer than is normal. So I usually left about an hour before Google's suggestion to give me enough buffer time.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by mark_l_watson on Monday June 05, 2017 @09:04PM (#14493900)
I have the same useful advice added when I travel which is why before big trips, I switch on GMail (start forwarding my private email to GMail) and while traveling enable location detection. Really useful - while traveling.

But, I don't travel that often so most of the time I just use FastMail and run my phone without location detection enabled.

For me, this is a good compromise between taking advantage to Google services when I travel and the rest of the time at least try to opt out of sharing so much of my data.

Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by accountyaccount on Monday June 05, 2017 @09:55PM (#14494113)
Another one:

After taking photos of a whiteboard at work, Google collected them and asked me if I wanted to archive my photos of notes (it knew they were notes!) so I could declutter my gallery.

I feel like there's not enough hype around Google Photos. It's such a good photo platform. I could throw my phone out the window right now and be completely confident I'm not losing any photos of my family.

Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by amorphid on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @09:34AM (#14497063)
It's the first photo platform I've been willing to pay for!
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by TulliusCicero on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:23PM (#14492793)
An opt-in feature is a mostly dead feature. Your average users just uses the defaults. Opt-ins only make sense for power user features or ones where there is some really strong motivation for people to turn it on.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by click170 on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:35PM (#14493325)
I'm not arguing with your logic, but I the user searched for and found/installed the app/service, it's disappointing and disheartening to not be trusted to choose my own preferences and explore the options in said app/service.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by TulliusCicero on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @06:19AM (#14496110)
> it's disappointing and disheartening to not be trusted to choose my own preferences and explore the options in said app/service.

Except you are: if you're the kind of user who will take action and 'explore the options', why does it hurt you to have an opt-out instead of an opt-in? You would end up explicitly making the same choice anyway, right?

This is exactly why opt-outs for these kinds of features make sense: the average user would otherwise never even know the feature existed, and power users that are bothered by it are the ones who are willing to go into the options to disable it.

Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by bigbugbag on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:30PM (#14493284)
Terrifyingly creepy ! I'm happy I have banned everything "google"(alphabet) from my life 10+ years ago, the only alphabet service I still use occasionally is street view because it does not have an alternative.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by dublinben on Monday June 05, 2017 @11:18PM (#14494466)
There are at least two alternatives to Google Street View, OpenStreetCam and Mapillary, but their quality is nowhere close in most areas.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by dubya on Monday June 05, 2017 @10:33PM (#14494256)
The event detection really isn't good enough to rely on yet. I've also run into the problem that the default settings for auto-created events are bad. Things like an alarm 10 minutes before a flight, or appointments being hidden from the one person I share my calendar with.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by modeless on Monday June 05, 2017 @04:37PM (#14491696)
To disable a specific type of Maps notification, just tap on one and look at the bottom of the screen for the option to turn off that type of notification specifically. Or, there's a whole "notifications" section in settings that provides very fine-grained control. I'm surprised that you weren't able to find it if you looked for it.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by kibwen on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:16PM (#14492746)
From the notifications screen itself I've managed to find that you can partially swipe right on a notification to reveal a gear icon that allows one to mute all notifications from that app, but I've yet to find anything more fine-grained.

By "tap on one and look at the bottom of the screen", do you mean the notifications screen or in the Maps app itself? I'd expect tapping the notification itself to perform some action, which is why I've never done it. I don't have one to experiment with right now, maybe I should take some photos...

Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by modeless on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:23PM (#14492785)
In the Maps app. Android itself doesn't currently provide a way to separately control fine-grained notification categories, but they're adding it in the next version.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by angerbot on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:53PM (#14493029)
I've definitely had Google Now show me things to do when traveling. Usually it gives me lists of museums, places to eat, etc. I can't recall if it's ever done that without a plane ticket or airbnb/hotel reservation email for some context though.
Re:Why aren’t Google and Facebook enriching our lives more? by srathi on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:58PM (#14493489)
I think you get these notifications only if you are enrolled as a Google Local Guide. I may be wrong though.