News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Environmental Report by kuschku on Monday June 05, 2017 @12:30PM (#14488922)
> You can't remove entire TLDs once delegated and widely linked to. That's closing the barn door after the horse has escaped.

Why not?

We can also remove domains once registered and widely linked to.

The NIC of .eu just removed over 10'000 due to squatting.

Why shouldn’t we just remove Google’s TLDs where it’s squatting?

Re:Google’s Environmental Report by CydeWeys on Monday June 05, 2017 @01:32PM (#14489462)
TLDs are qualitatively quite different than second-level domain names.

Do you have a link to the .eu actions you're referring to?

And the simplest answer is contracts. Every operator of a new gTLD has paid ICANN a substantial amount of money, has a contract to operate the TLD, and thus has certain legal rights. The TLDs cannot be taken away without good cause. There is no language in the contracts requiring a certain number of domains be launched by a certain date, so that cannot be justification for removing the operation grant. And of course contracts cannot be unilaterally changed.

I am not a lawyer, this is my personal opinion and not my employer's, all other disclaimers, please consult your own lawyer or Wikipedia if you have questions about contract law, etc.

Re:Google’s Environmental Report by nebabyte on Monday June 05, 2017 @04:21PM (#14491467)
When people are arguing whether or not the ramifications would be significant, you can't point to ink and call it blood.

Laws can be overturned, the legality of contracts overruled, recompenses rewarded. There's nothing "irrevocable" here, aside from the dangerous precedents people try and establish and sit on ("it's always been this way!!1") hoping to "run out the clock" and get away with moves that would never have flown in a later world.

Re:Google’s Environmental Report by kuschku on Monday June 05, 2017 @03:17PM (#14490507)
Here’s the example case: https://www.out-law.com/page-8457

But EURid also de-registers almost all other domain squatters, as they actually wrote that into the contract.

> And the simplest answer is contracts.

Contracts are simply something enforced by law. Law can be changed. If not, law is simply something enforced by society and constitutions, constitutions can be changed.

The German constitution, for example, says that the right to own property only exists as long as that property is used for public good. In any other case, it can be seized.

Seizing the TLDs, or requiring DNS servers in your country to redirect the TLDs to other operators, would be an option.

And, as drastic as this sounds, it’s preferable over the current situation. Corporate squatting is inacceptable.

Re:Google’s Environmental Report by CydeWeys on Monday June 05, 2017 @03:30PM (#14490663)
Yes, that case is an example of a qualitative difference between TLDs and SLDs. .eu, as a ccTLD for the European Union, has a TLD-wide policy that all registrants must be based in the European Economic Area. Those 10K domain names were all registered by a Chinese woman who used a fake address in London to register the domain names. So they are being fought over in court not because of "squatting", but because she violated the registry policy.

Note that it is up to the registry operator to set said policy (which ICANN must approve). So that mechanism does not even exist to take away a TLD.

Good luck in getting international law passed to take away TLDs from corporations. I just don't see it happening.

> Seizing the TLDs, or requiring DNS servers in your country to redirect the TLDs to other operators, would be an option.

This would break the Internet. Domain names have to work the same everywhere. You cannot have domain names pointing to different DNS zones entirely depending on where you access them from.

Re:Google’s Environmental Report by kuschku on Monday June 05, 2017 @05:22PM (#14492219)
> This would break the Internet. Domain names have to work the same everywhere. You cannot have domain names pointing to different DNS zones entirely depending on where you access them from.

Domain names point to different DNS zones already today, everywhere.

First of all, anycast DNS is a common example.

Second, there’s massive government censorship in many countries, including the UK, and there’s also some US ISPs that modify any and all DNS queries for some domains (noticeable by the fact that DNSSEC-enabled domains are stripped of the signature, and return a false A record there).

> Good luck in getting international law passed to take away TLDs from corporations. I just don't see it happening.

Doesn’t have to be international

> This would break the Internet.

So? Giving corporations any control over the Internet has turnt out to be the far more breaking move already.

Google, for example, has recently massively destroyed support for IDN domains in Google Chrome – and no one bat an eye, despite it leading to billions in costs for many people and companies, some of which even had used an IDN domain in their trademark, and were now unable to use it.

Removing these new TLDs is a far smaller change.