News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whatever Happened to Voice Recognition? by compay on Monday June 21, 2010 @09:20AM (#1448696)
It's more than just linguistic software. Our knowledge of linguistics itself is currently very limited; it's a nacent science and there's still a great deal of debate about how to even approach the study of language. Even leaving aside the difficulties in just transcribing speech, linguists are still a long ways off from coming up with any formalism of human syntax that could help create software to syntactically parse normal human speech.
Re:Whatever Happened to Voice Recognition? by CWuestefeld on Monday June 21, 2010 @09:27AM (#1448707)
...because most of our linguistic formalism is derived from written language, which is generally an artificial approximation of real language.

Remember grade school, with parts of speech, Conjunction Junction, and diagramming sentences? Well, think back to the last (non-trivial) sentence you actually said out loud. I challenge you to try to diagram that sentence.

Although there's quite a lot of research that's been done, surprisingly little of it deals with the way most of us really communicate.

Re:Whatever Happened to Voice Recognition? by compay on Monday June 21, 2010 @10:33AM (#1448906)
Modern linguistic formalism is not derived from written language at all. I studied at MIT and UConn in the mid '90's and the separation between prescriptive grammar and linguistics is pretty clear.

That's not to say that current approaches to linguistics are correct; I don't know enough to make that judgement. But I think the problem lies more in the complexity of the domain - not because modern linguists are so foolish as to base theory on written language.

Re:Whatever Happened to Voice Recognition? by CWuestefeld on Monday June 21, 2010 @12:00PM (#1449165)
It's quite possible I'm behind the times.

not because modern linguists are so foolish as to base theory on written language

That was actually what I was trying to get at. While there are clearly some rules we follow when speaking, they are much more open than those governing our writing.

It's odd, though, or at least counterintuitive, that our comprehensive of these less-structured spoken communications is higher than that of more-structured written ones.

Re:Whatever Happened to Voice Recognition? by woodson on Monday June 21, 2010 @09:49AM (#1448768)
In fact, it has been shown that there are languages that have syntactic constructions which are context-sensitive (in a generative linguistic PoV. cf. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chomsky_hierarchy). For example Swiss German variants (http://books.google.com/books?id=JOjoWrP4tnIC&lpg=PA165&...)