When yahoo first started out (and at that time I was using it) the role it played was equivalent to that which search engines play today. At that point in time there were no search engines, the only way to know about a website was to already have the address, or two read someplace that referenced or linked to it. Yahoo was initially "just a list of websites" but the role it played was very much the role that Google plays for so many people today: the site you start out on, and the place you go if you want to find something on the Internet.
They eventually lost that role to search engines like Alta Vista, and later incarnations of Yahoo became a"Portal": a site you go to because it has decent implementations of many different features such as news, movie listings, stock quotes, and everything else that Yahoo offers.
More specifically - you went there and could "search" the directory. You put in a word or phrase and it searched the directory listings to find matches. It was just only searching its own very limited set of info, vs a crawled index of all the content of the sites. IIRC, they'd also started charging ($250 IIRC?) for adding a listing to their directory sometime in the late 90s or so.
I was commenting to someone the other day that I still have friends with AOL email addresses. In the BBS days, that was how those without Internet access could communicate with those that were "surfin' the net".
It goes deeper than that ... the trend is not to become a portal but rather, to become "the phone company".
Everyone is trying to become "the phone company" in which they attain a central, monopoly position through which all communication takes place.
Google and Facebook are currently fighting for that spot. They're trying to become AOL, but more deeply, like AOL before them, they're all just trying to become ma bell.
This is very convincingly explained in the very highly regarded book _The Master Switch_, by Tim Wu.
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/dec/12/ratio-tec...
Is it the nature of network effects that drives this somewhat characteristic industry dynamic?
I have a theory that there's always at least one big web portal - AOL started as a dial-up ISP and turned into a portal. Yahoo started as a search engine and turned into a portal. Facebook started as a social network and turned into a portal.