As it turns out, there are at least 2 ways you can create value to society here:
1) Reduce spreads.
2) Stabilise prices.
Now, whether it makes any sense to put to work all those bright minds for these purposes, is a question the society should have asked some time ago...
Adjusted to average growth of stock market (and inflation), it is a zero sum game. You aren't creating value by predicting the future. Just like you don't create value when you predict which lottery ticket will win.