News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by Jabanga on Friday June 02, 2017 @09:42PM (#14474489)
Collective bargaining is never mandatory on the employee side. The employee is not forced to work for a particular collective. The employer on the otherhand is forced, by law, to only hire people who are part of some government-recognized collective, known as a bargaining unit.

In other words, employees can monopolize the employer's hiring options, using anti-free-market laws inspired by the 'labour' movement and socialism.

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by InclinedPlane on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:56PM (#14474767)
That's not how unions work in the US.
Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by metaphor on Saturday June 03, 2017 @08:15AM (#14476029)
Feel free to enlighten us anytime.

The parent has accurately described my experience, and I'm in the US.

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by mikeash on Friday June 02, 2017 @09:54PM (#14474533)
Being forced to join a union looks like equality to me. If I want to work at a particular place, I have to join that company. I can't come in on my own, expect to get paid, but not be a part of the company that runs the place. Why should the union be any different?

If an employee doesn't want to work for a particular company, they have to find a different place to work. If an employee doesn't want to join a particular union, they have to find a different place to work. Why is the former reasonable but not the latter?

If an employer really wants to hire non-union labor, they can leave their company and join a different one that doesn't have a union. You're playing an interesting semantic trick here where you use "employee" to refer to the individual, but "employer" to refer to the company. You thereby paint the asymmetry as unfair, when in fact there's no expectation that they should be the same. Let's compare individuals to individuals (laborers to management, say) and groups to groups (companies to unions).

Why do the arguments against unions not also apply to companies? Give me something where if I replace "union" with "company" the result isn't an equally compelling argument against not letting employers organize collectively.

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by altstar on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:07PM (#14474593)
The relationship between you as an employee and employer is totally different than you and a (potential) union. The one is paying you a salary for certain work done. The other is to (potentially) help you to negotiate better working conditions. You are absolutely making no sense at all.
Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by chimeracoder on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:23PM (#14474648)
> The one is paying you a salary for certain work done. The other is to (potentially) help you to negotiate better working conditions

That's like saying that the role of elected officials is to represent their constituents and serve their interests, treating them all with full equality under the law.

It's a nice statement, but it's completely idealistic and doesn't accurately describe what actually happens in practice.

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by testrun on Saturday June 03, 2017 @09:24AM (#14476270)
wtf? You work for a salary and you join a union if you want better working conditions and believe that is the only way to get it. This is not rocket science. What does politics have to do with it?
Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by mikeash on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:42PM (#14474708)
As an employee, the union is an organization you belong to which works to further your interests, and the company is an outside organization in a hopefully symbiotic relationship, where you provide them with things they want, and they provide you with things you want.

As an employer, the company is an organization you belong to which works to further your interests, and the union is an outside organization in a hopefully symbiotic relationship, where you provide them with things they want, and they provide you with things you want.

I am not saying that an employee has the same relationship with their union and their company. I'm saying that when you break it down into employee/employer and company/union, it becomes fairly symmetrical. Look at the individuals on both sides, and then at the organizations on both sides. If one side shouldn't band together, why should the other side do so?

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by pdonis on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:10PM (#14474806)
> As an employee, the union is an organization you belong to which works to further your interests

If that were actually true, it would be nice. But I doubt it's true for very many unions. Certainly my past experience in the auto industry indicated that it was not the case for the UAW, which is the union involved in this particular case.

> If one side shouldn't band together, why should the other side do so?

My personal belief is that unions should take this to its logical conclusion. If they really believe they can manage working conditions better than the employers, they should back that claim up by becoming full-fledged for-profit corporations, employing the workers they represent and negotiating contracts with the companies that want the services of those workers. If union claims are true, this arrangement should be a win-win: employees now work directly for the organization that represents them, and companies that want those services get them cheaper because the union can provide them more efficiently since they now employ the workers directly instead of being an inefficient middleman.

If this were actually done and worked, it would be great. But I won't hold my breath waiting for it.

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by mikeash on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:24PM (#14474850)
Your "logical conclusion" sounds like the proliferation of third-party suppliers which I understand is now a huge part of the auto industry. Sure, they're companies rather than unions, but my underlying point is that the two aren't particularly different: they're both ways for people to band together and get better deals collectively than they would individually.

In any case, I'm not saying unions should do this or that, or that we should necessarily cheer them on. I just want the same standards applied to both sides. It looks to me like people decry unions based on things that are not unique to them, but give companies a free pass.

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by pdonis on Saturday June 03, 2017 @12:47AM (#14475060)
> the proliferation of third-party suppliers which I understand is now a huge part of the auto industry

Yes, it is, even more so now then when I was working in the industry. But that's something different from what I'm talking about. At each of the factories run by those third-party suppliers, the workers are employees of the supplier company. (And many of those factories are also unionized under the UAW.) Similarly, at the assembly plants where finished vehicles are put together from the parts from all of those third-party suppliers, the workers are employees of the auto company (GM or Ford or Toyota or whomever), and (mostly) unionized under the UAW. (AFAIK that's true of all the plants of the US auto companies, but some foreign ones, like Toyota, have US plants that are not unionized.)

What I'm describing is something different: a factory belonging to GM or Ford or whomever, but staffed by workers (and supervisors up to whatever level seems appropriate) who are employees of, say, the Auto Workers' Company (AWC), which is a full-fledged, for-profit corporation that specializes in representing and managing automotive factory workers. That company negotiates a contract with the company that owns the factory and supplies it with raw materials and ships out its finished products, just like any other contract between companies. The contract specifies what jobs the workers are to do and under what conditions, and the factory owner pays the AWC for the services it provides according to whatever payment terms are in the contract. The AWC then pays the workers, since they are its employees.

> It looks to me like people decry unions based on things that are not unique to them, but give companies a free pass.

I don't see companies getting a free pass, but I also think that, to the extent that unions get decried more than companies, it's because unions combine the worst features of companies and democracies:

- Unions have a corporate command structure (they have officers, finances, etc.), but it's subject to democratic rule (members vote on the leadership). Thus, the leadership has a long-term mission (to sustain the viability of the labor pool), but a short-term focus.

- Unions have, or at least try to have, monopoly power. This means that the actual benefits they can provide from collective action (which is what makes it more sensible for them to be corporations) are more than swallowed up in the deadweight losses associated with having the monopoly (which is demanded by the membership for the same reasons people in a democracy demand government benefits).

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by Jabanga on Saturday June 03, 2017 @08:49PM (#14479328)
>If an employer really wants to hire non-union labor, they can leave their company and join a different one that doesn't have a union.

This makes no sense. The employer shouldn't be forced to 'have a union'. It's not a voluntary relationship, and thus it totally violates the company owner's right to their own private property.

Unions as they exist today are rent-seeking organizations that prey on employers. No wonder investors invest in other countries, and companies outsource.

Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by jgrowl on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:16PM (#14474622)
So if someone should either be forced to join a union that they don't want to be apart of or just find another job. Doesn't this kinda provide an argument against unionizing in the first place? If you are joining a company that isn't part of a union you accepting that fact... why should employees be allowed to unionize when that it is against the wishes of the pre-existing wishes of the company?
Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by mikeash on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:38PM (#14474701)
I agree that this is an argument against unions, but only to the extent that it is also an argument against companies. Swap union/company and employee/employer in your argument and it remains just as valid.
Re:Workers involved in union activities say Tesla is illegal... by Jabanga on Saturday June 03, 2017 @08:53PM (#14479345)
They're not the same arguments at all. The corollary would be if you started working for a company, and the company then created a union with other companies, and made it illegal for you to work for any company other than those that are part of this corporate union.

In a free society, a company would be able to fire its workers for unionizing and hire new ones.