News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Convincing C programmers to switch to C++: A look at huma... by haberman on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:13PM (#14471596)
The article is a 4,000 word diatribe about how stubborn, irrational people refuse to see reason, without at any point admitting the possibility that these backward, incorrigible C holdouts could be right in any way.
Re:Convincing C programmers to switch to C++: A look at huma... by jordigh on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:40PM (#14471863)
It's not about C holdouts being unreasonable at all. They're only mentioned in the first three paragraphs of the article. The article isn't about C or C++. It's about why you and I are arguing right now: we're both irrational.
Re:Convincing C programmers to switch to C++: A look at huma... by haberman on Friday June 02, 2017 @02:01PM (#14472033)
> It's not about C holdouts being unreasonable at all. They're only mentioned in the first three paragraphs of the article.

That's not true; they are mentioned several times in the first big bullet list. Also the Dan Saks talk he discusses several times throughout the article is specifically about talking to C programmers about C++.

But regardless of whether he is speaking about something specific (C vs. C++) or in the abstract (rational vs. irrational people), he is making the same flawed presumption: that certain choices (like C++) are unquestionably better than other choices (like C), and that if people can't see this then the only possible explanation is some kind of cognitive impairment.

The whole argument presumes that the author is smarter and more rational than other people. He might not even realize he is doing this, but other people can most definitely pick up on it.

Re:Convincing C programmers to switch to C++: A look at huma... by jordigh on Friday June 02, 2017 @02:58PM (#14472455)
> The whole argument presumes that the author is smarter

Aha, so that's why everyone is posting comments about how terrible C++ is. The author is coming across like an ass, so we must attack that which he appears to be defending: C++.

I don't really pick up on the bad attitude (probably because I have it too), and I don't really care that much to defend C++ or C. I went through the article, noted a few references to whatever psychological studies were there, and decided to read those later. I don't really care if C or C++ is "better". I barely use either anymore.