And sometimes you make seemingly illogical decisions that end up being objectively worse decisions. The problem is that we don't really have a way to quantify our emotions usefully, which means we can use them accurately and are forced to allow for enormous amounts of error in our calculations when we provide any level of significance to them. That's why they are often seen as detrimental to rational decisions, not because they don't matter (obviously emotions do), but because including them sometimes leaves us no better off than flipping a coin (are the downsides really that bad, or is your fear of change in this instance vastly overwhelming the other considerations, and in an unwarranted way that you aren't entirely aware of?).
If that theory is true (not sure, I literally just learned about it this morning[1]), your emotions do have weight in something like this, but it's filtered through multiple lossy abstractions and has a propensity for false positives. That's a much less rosy interpretation of how useful they are, and if true, means we might be far better off trying to cultivate a better understanding of the nuances that are causing those reactions and assessing them rationally (to the degree possible) than to using the lossy abstraction itself with any significant weight.
1: http://www.pc.rhul.ac.uk/sites/lab/index.php/research-themes...
To think you understood everything before you started and insist on sticking to that after you find it's not working out isn't rational, it's stubborn.
I still vastly prefer C++ over C though :P