News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by cjlars on Friday June 02, 2017 @03:56AM (#14468265)
The key issue is that a lot of startups use various contractual terms -- things like options on exit, liquidation preferences and others -- to take money into into the business at high nominal valuations, while still offering downside protection (optionality) to investors. The public at large usually just quotes the nominal valuation and goes from there. However, the optionality of those terms has substantial financial value, so the nominal valuation is often far from the truth.

These authors have developed a system to tease out the optionality using standard financial methods (using methods like Black-Scholes, for example), which can give us all a better understanding of the true worth of these companies. Far overdue in my opinion.

Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by deepGem on Friday June 02, 2017 @05:12AM (#14468558)
I totally agree. A startup founder has to spend so much time and energy understanding these preferential downside protections. Raising money is so time consuming solely for this reason. If everyone were to just stick to the fundamentals of simple accounting, the startup world would be a far better place. I really appreciate what these professors have done.
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by gjem97 on Friday June 02, 2017 @08:43AM (#14469409)
FWIW, this is what a 409A valuation is supposed to do. But that is often done long after a funding round is closed. The PR people and journos need a simple number to report on the story as the deal is announced. I would argue nobody really knows what the company is worth at that point (with the exception of the new lead investor, who may have a model for it).
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by jsw97 on Friday June 02, 2017 @09:54AM (#14469871)
Interestingly, the authors look at 409A valuations, which funnily enough have the opposite problem. From the article: "Low values reduce taxes; coincidentally, 409A valuations commonly use questionable assumptions that significantly deflate values." (p. 8)
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by bogomipz on Friday June 02, 2017 @09:17AM (#14469612)
>" while still offering downside protection (optionality) to investors."

I'm not familiar with tern "optionality" can you say what that is and how it provides downside risk protection to investors? Thanks.

Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by bjterry on Friday June 02, 2017 @09:33AM (#14469725)
Optionality basically just means that there isn't a straightforward linear relationship between the price of something and how much you earn out of it. It's a very general term.

With preferred shares, investors have the option of taking either some percent of the company, or of instead taking a flat payment equal to their original investment (or more). For example, if a venture investor invested $100 into your lemonade stand, they could choose either to get the first $100 when you sold the stand, or to get 20% of the sale price. As long as you sold it under $500, they would take their $100 back, but if you sold it over $500 they would take 20%. If you sold it under $100, they would get all of it. That's the downside protection, since you'd be left with less than 80% of the proceeds even though nominally you own 80% of the business.

Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by gjem97 on Friday June 02, 2017 @09:26AM (#14469673)
The optionality in startup investing has mainly to do with the "limited liability" in Limited Liability Corporation (other types of corporations and partnerships also have limited liability). That is, if you invest a dollar in a corporation, your losses are capped at a dollar. But, your gains are potentially infinite. Another instrument that has that characteristic--limited downside and infinite upside--is an option. The startup equity isn't actually an option, but it is useful to discuss its "optionality" because it does have some similar characteristics.
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by bogomipz on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:01AM (#14469916)
Thanks for the explanation.

A related question I have then is would RSUs be considered as providing downside risk(but no upside) for employees then as the value is independent of the companies actual performance?

Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by jsjohnst on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:46AM (#14470257)
I'm far from an expect, but unless I'm misunderstanding your question, no, that's not it. RSUs negate some of the downside risk for an employee (vs an option), but have similar upside. With an RSU, it has value as long as the company has value, with an option, it has no value unless the sell price is above the strike price.
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by bogomipz on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:53AM (#14470319)
I probably didn't articulate that as well as I could have. You answered my question though thanks. I actually don't hear about RSUs as much except for some unicorns that seem to be staying private for longer and longer.
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by jsjohnst on Saturday June 03, 2017 @10:38AM (#14476553)
Many publicly traded companies issue RSUs over options these days. But yeah, many startups don't.
Re:New research indicates ‘Unicorns’ are overvalued by bogomipz on Saturday June 03, 2017 @05:06PM (#14478491)
Yes, I think that RSUs are the most common form of stock grants for publicly traded companies. I think FB might hae been one the first SV companies to use it for employees pre-IPO.