Re:OneLogin suffers breach–customer data said to be exposed,...
by nucleardog on Thursday June 01, 2017 @02:13PM
(#14462887)
I don't know what options are still available, but the "3rd party" thing is why I ended up paying $100 or something to purchase 1Password back when it was still only available as a one-time-purchased standalone app.
Even if it's open source, I'm in no position to effectively evaluate their crypto/etc. But I can do some basic reasoning about the possible attack surfaces.
With 1Password I hold all my data, and the software that I use to view it runs completely independently of anything else. Besides a takeover of my local machine or breaking the encryption, nobody gets my data.
With something like LastPass, they hold all my data. The software that I use to view it runs in my browser. The software handling all my passwords is running in the same program that I use to execute untrusted code from the internet thousands of times a day. This has bitten them in the ass a few times.
I'd love an open source password manager solution given the turn 1Password has taken towards being a "cloud service", but for the love of god can it please be useful without tying it to my web browser.
Even if it's open source, I'm in no position to effectively evaluate their crypto/etc. But I can do some basic reasoning about the possible attack surfaces.
With 1Password I hold all my data, and the software that I use to view it runs completely independently of anything else. Besides a takeover of my local machine or breaking the encryption, nobody gets my data.
With something like LastPass, they hold all my data. The software that I use to view it runs in my browser. The software handling all my passwords is running in the same program that I use to execute untrusted code from the internet thousands of times a day. This has bitten them in the ass a few times.
I'd love an open source password manager solution given the turn 1Password has taken towards being a "cloud service", but for the love of god can it please be useful without tying it to my web browser.