News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't F# more popular? by pkese on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:03AM (#14459067)
I think the main problem is that F# never went beyond .Net platform (e.g. they never released a native compiler). .Net is nice and gets the work done, but the fact that existing .Net libraries are OOP style means 1) they don't fit as nicely into the F# paradigms (see other people's answers) and 2) adoption is easy for people already familiar with .net and not as easy for people coming from other languages/platforms.

In addition, inside the .Net world, F# got a role of just "And you can even do functional programming in .Net if you like", rather than "this is a proper way of how people should write safe high-level code". I think Ximian is the only one giving F# proper handling.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't F# more popular? by pkese on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:18AM (#14459122)
It might be worth also looking into ReasonML, which is a very similar language, but gets some of F# issues right, like:

  - Targeting native compilation and javascript transpilation out of the box
  - Proper functionally architected libraries
  - (including React and React-native for GUIs)
  - Ocaml style functors
  - Easy syntax for people who are familiar with javascript
  - Prime-time promotion by a large company (Facebook)
  - Targeting unikernels (i.e. MirageOS) makes it geek/buzzword compliant
The only downside for ReasonML right now I guess is that the tooling and developer experience (especially on Windows) is nowhere near to what F# / .Net core / VS Code+Ionide already offers on all platforms (Win/OSX/Linux).