I mean, I know a ton of obscure and esoteric languages. Do I turn to them, even the cool ones, when I want to implement some idea I have? I'm afraid I often turn to the tried and tested boring languages because of the network effect. Increasingly I just use raw javascript, which is right up there with VB and PHP for unpopularity, just because it makes it damn easy to share the result with others if its in a web-page.
And then the motivation to pick up not only a new language but a whole new paradigm just doesn't seem that urgent or appealing, especially when compared to that new bit of infrastructure which will oh-so-obviously add a significant new tool to your toolbelt.
I consider myself fluent in Python.
But in my case, that was the extra reason to try to learn something new and different, and after searching for a suitable second language, I kinda settled for F#. (I have also tried Haskell, but never managed to move past some basic examples)
Productivity isn't always measured by direct output. If I write something with 20% overhead that is 3x more robust, then it's worth it. This is what I see F#/Clojure/Haskell providing.
- it's hard to hire people
- most libraries are written for OO style so most code will be written OO style
- most sample code is written in C#
- C# is a pretty nice language. Does F# really provide an advantage?
- will MS abandon F#?
I really would like to see a clear case for F#. When you consider factors like hiring and existing ecosystem the case for F# is not clear to me.
Another data-wrangling thing easier in F# (not FP in general) is type-providers.
Many other commentators said something like this, so it seems to me that:
Not many people are using F#, because it's hard to find employer who needs F#. And employers don't seek for F# programmers, because there are too few of them.
Also since all popular and dominant languages are either Object Oriented and/or Imperative, functional programming concepts seem too alien.
Even though I consider myself a fairly passionate programmer, I haven't found enough incentive to invest proper time to learn a purely functional language. The infatuation with Clojure and Haskell only lasted for a weekend for me. I always think, that next month I am going to invest in learning a functional language, but always something else more shiny comes along from other domain like, Dynamo DB, Firebase, RabbitMQ, etc. Which I find more practical to learn rather than learning yet another programming language.