I arrived at the hotel, they noted my HHonors basic membership and mentioned I wasn't receiving points due to booking with third party. I said I got the room for 10% less than their best online rate and their response was that I should have called bookings to talk to them. So now there's even more hoops to jump through to book direct? No thanks.
Price matching is great when it works, but infuriating when you can't actually back it up. It should all be automated, I can't imagine someone at Hilton is manually setting HotelTonight prices and not telling anyone.
Some processes and business practices are super hard to change.
Hotels will almost always match lowest rate because they care much more about having low vacancy and not having to pay booking.com for your reservation. And you won't sacrifice points or chances at upgrades.
Booking.com is a good way of finding low prices that hotels will match.
Disclosure: Used to work at TripAdvisor.
I booked for a noticeably (~10%) cheaper price directly through a hotel website, but I wasn't able to get just a room. I had to book a package which included free tickets to a nearby tourist spot.
Try checking from your phone while it is disconnected from your personal network.
Yeah, that's a load of crap. I always start with an aggregator, and if I find a place that I like, I check their website as well. Unless they're cheaper or offer some major perks, I book through the 3rd party site. Of the last 5 hotels I've booked, going through a 3rd party site has been a better deal 4 of those times.