News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by jacquesm on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:47AM (#14443781)
Interesting, the best I could find was lawyer. Politician wasn't available, I suspect that is the safest job of all, if it should ever become threatened they will simply pass a law that makes that illegal.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by veli_joza on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:37AM (#14444254)
Your reasoning works if you think of "robotic takeover" as some isolated event that threatens existing politicians. I see it as gradual change.

It could start with politicians leaning on AI to make better-informed economic decisions, or to predict the voters response to proposed policies. That would force other parties/governments to either do the same or fade to obscurity. This change would be spread out over longer period, but I don't see politics as safe haven.

Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by jacquesm on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:57AM (#14444348)
I really don't see 'vote for algorithm x' as an option in any democracy.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by onion2k on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:54AM (#14443822)
I looked up lawyers too (https://willrobotstakemyjob.com/23-1011-lawyers). Given the fact that a lot of the legal research and discovery work that lawyers do is already being done by software instead of junior level humans, I think that number is completely wrong. A lot of legal work outside of negotiation is essentially data transformation and interpretation which is exactly what machine learning is good for. Law is probably second to accounting for massive disruption in the next few years, but it's a close call.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by jacquesm on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:02AM (#14443859)
Being a practicing lawyer is steeped in tradition and all kinds of archaic things (wigs?). What I meant by 'lawyer' is not paralegal or research but being admitted to the bar and allowed to practice law. I really don't see a computer getting a pass on that anytime soon simply because the bar association is made up of lawyers.

That research can be aided and may be done by a computer is beyond dispute at this point, but that job is called being a 'paralegal'.

Being a paralegal is usually a step to becoming a lawyer so I can see a bit of a continuity problem there.

Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by barrkel on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:06AM (#14444135)
The continuity problem will crop up across lots of disciplines, though. When we automate, we'll probably start out at the lower ends of every discipline, crowding out juniors where they'd normally onboard. That won't be too threatening to senior stakeholders in the discipline, either, so they may let it happen. And then automation will creep its way up the value chain; there'll be strong pressure for it to do so, because with automation making the onramp harder to get onto, there will be an increasing scarcity (and thus increasing profit motive) to climb the value chain.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by BenderV on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:06AM (#14444136)
We, at Doctrine (doctrine.fr), are "automating" the search/discovery/legal monitoring. So, we are disrupting the low-level, groundwork so lawyers can focus on higher level tasks.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by QML on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:03AM (#14443861)
This was what I was telling my friend: management, legal research, and medical diagnosis are places where machine learning will flourish in the incoming years as (I hope I'm not oversimplifying this) those processes depend on looking up specific cases and inferring a condition from them.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by adamcharnock on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:55AM (#14443824)
Try teachers. 'Teachers and Instructors, All Other' has 0.85%, although teachers assistants don't do so well.
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by robpethick on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:07AM (#14443881)
According to this data - the safest is Recreational Therapists. However I suspect you are correct about Politicians...
Re:Will Robots Take My Job? by notauser on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:52AM (#14443814)
Sales Engineer was the lowest I could see - 0.4% risk of automation.

Much better than 3.5% for lawyers and 13% for software developers.