https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dietary_fiber
"In some countries fiber is not listed on nutrition labels and is considered to provide no energy. In other countries all fiber must be listed and is simplistically considered to provide 17 kJ/g (4.1 kcal/g) (because chemically fiber is a type of carbohydrate and other carbohydrates provide that amount of energy). In the US, soluble fiber must be counted as 4 kcal/g (17 kJ/g), but insoluble fiber may be (and usually is) treated as not providing energy and not mentioned on the label."
This obviously isn't practical for every day use but the data has been used to approximate calories out correlated with heart rate if body weight is known - several sports watches such as Suunto use this approach.
So I would say the mask method is the BEST way, but not necessarily accurate.
So I tend also to favor something that teaches people long lasting lifestyle changes and habits rewiring instead. This will be personal and different for everyone. Many lifestyle can work, and each can choose their own.
But nothing is novel about this. The article hints at something novel, of the sort that if you changed your gut microbiome you might suddenly lose weight even if you keep eating the same way, because the body would metabolise differently. Or that each person has foods that make them fat, and if you identify what they are and cut them out, you can eat an infinite amount of the rest and you won't get fat. This would be really novel, but I failed to see proof of this in the article.
This is exactly what I'm trying to do with my diet experiments, though for general health, not just weight loss:
"a future step for researchers could be to identify probiotics or diets that encourage the right kinds of microbes to grow to promote weight loss."
It isn't just calories in, calories out. There are other ways to lose weight that suggest there are other things at work.
- https://www.sciencealert.com/human-trials-will-test-freeze-d...
- http://www.cnn.com/2016/09/25/health/fecal-bacteria-obesity/
It makes me conclude that to sustain weight loss you simply need to be very motivated, have good discispline and great patience.
It seems they adapted strategies based on people's motivation. The girl who found logging all her meals too tedious instead adopted a more exercise strategy, etc. Nothing seems related to identifying which nutrients or foods are better processed, etc, for each individual.
I'm sure there could be genetic, social, or chemical related causes to obesity, but I'm not seeing this article say that we identified any of those. It seems to all be about simply getting your act together and sticking with it.
I suspect most people who gain back the weight lost do not do so while maintening the diet they used to lose it. The article makes it sound like so, but doesn't actually says so.