News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Britain's master forger by pmoriarty on Saturday May 27, 2017 @06:54PM (#14432299)
It takes a lot of technical skill at copying, yes. But that's not enough for a number of reasons.

First, that's not the same as the skill in creating the artwork to begin with. For example, an artist make create an original painting from a live model or from his imagination. The copier may have no such ability, or may have a very weak ability at doing that. They might be great at taking an artwork that's already made and copying it, though. Pretty different skills.

Then there's the choice of subject matter, the composition, what of him/herself the artists brings to the art, the artist's own style (not the style of some other artist he/she is copying) are all things that a pure copier does not have and can not bring to the creation of the copy with it ceasing to be a faithful copy.

Now, if the forger is, like the subject of the article in question, creating some of his own works in the style of another artist, without outright copying their work, then they are being more of an artist in their own right rather than just a copying machine. But they're still far removed from making their own art -- something the forger in the article was all too well aware of.

"I view my life as a failure. I went the wrong way. I could have done something useful. If I could have my time again, I’d like to be a teacher at an art college."

"The problem is that I can’t find my own style," he says. "Whenever I think of an idea for a piece, I know who it’s copying. I always see something of someone else in everything I do. I don’t have an original style."

Some non-artists might not be able to understand this distinction, but it's crystal clear to most artists.

Re:Britain's master forger by theoh on Saturday May 27, 2017 @11:15PM (#14432946)
That distinction is very familiar to me. Forgeries are pastiches. Leaving behind the business of painting, a lot of art these days -- performance, conceptual --would be equally difficult (or easy) to forge because it communicates a particular attitude or state of affairs, truthful or phony. Graphic designers ("commercial artists") or advertising art directors know that their business is communicating a particular desired state of affairs, regardless of whether it actually "obtains" as they say in philosophy.

If you accept that all the things we call art are very broadly and fundamentally concerned with that (making a convincing statement, not necessarily a likeness of reality) then it's really clear how a class of skilled imitators can exist who can't come up with the "opinions" themselves. Why anyone should care whether a particular work is a product of original thought or not is the big, dangerous issue that forgery raises.