Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous
by aub3bhat on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:06PM
(#14431428)
"fearmongering at a scale unseen before" is reasonable response when the argument uses words like "dystopian".
Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous
by JumpCrisscross on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:26PM
(#14431552)
You have never seen anyone call anything dystopian before?
Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous
by intended on Sunday May 28, 2017 @09:23AM
(#14434292)
Aadhar is definitionally dystopian.
In case people are unaware
> No fundamental right to privacy to citizens: Centre tells SC
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/No-fundamental-righ...
thats from 2015.
Aadhar has regularly been pushed in violation of SC verdicts for ever.
Until 2016, and the enshrinment of the 2016 act, it wasn't even with parliamentary backing - AND it was still pushed.
At every level, aadhar has been abused and misused, publicly and on record.
It is dystopian
Such hyperbole weakens your argument. It's borderline zealous. I don't think you are a zealot and I think you have a valid argument, although I disagree with you. But expressing good thoughts in hyperbole is not effective here.
(Another example is the "no right to criticise" argument. Nobody cares who has a legal right to do disagree. This isn't a court of law. All we care about are good arguments. If someone is hypocritical, point that out. But people can be hypocritical while still having a good point.)