News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Too many prisons make people worse by boomboomsubban on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:19PM (#14431199)
Every situation involves them losing their freedom. Even in this cage free prison they are stuck there under someone else's control. This is a punishment, and I don't see why justice needs more than this. A victim may wish for harsher punishment, but that won't actually help their problems.
Re:Too many prisons make people worse by cbanek on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:52PM (#14431668)
Totally agree. Vengeance sounds great until you get it - and you realize you still have the same problems, and maybe a few new ones.

Perhaps like rehabilitating offenders, we also need to rehabilitate victims as well. Being a victim can be as troubling than being an offender because it's not really in your control. This can really be hard on people, especially mental health, PTSD, anxiety, fear of people, etc.

I'm not even sure such a system exists - it seems like the victim would be on their own for finding care and help with that?

Re:Too many prisons make people worse by tripzilch on Sunday May 28, 2017 @10:25AM (#14434464)
In the Netherlands there is a program for exactly that, "slachtofferhulp" ("victim help"). I'm not entirely sure what it entails, but I've been offered it even after merely witnessing the shop on the corner of my street being robbed from a distance (the thief ran past me just as I stepped outside my house, so I made a statement to the police).

Well okay he did threaten me, raising the knife while saying "don't even think about it" [standing in his way/stopping him]. But he didn't come at me, and I was certain I could have outrun him if he did (by running towards the shop, which he was focused on getting away from, after all), I remained at distance. Of course, this being the Netherlands, there was about zero risk the guy would pull a gun (especially after brandishing a rather cheap looking chef's knife).

Re:Too many prisons make people worse by rectang on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:36PM (#14431265)
Exactly. Taking away someone's liberty is a substantial punishment, and the imposition of longer sentences for more serious crimes should slake the natural desire for vengeance to some degree.

But the victim is not the only stakeholder in the justice system. There are also the accused (prisoner's rights), and society at large (lower recidivism). The interests of all need to be balanced.

Re:Too many prisons make people worse by tripzilch on Sunday May 28, 2017 @10:05AM (#14434413)
Justice needs more than this because victims will wish for harsher punishment. The public will not feel satisfied and trust in the justice system will lessen, etc. You can tell people but you can't honestly expect the whole of society to just become "enlightened" about this. Desire for vengeance is a thing, it lives in us, and even though I can personally (usually) rationally decide to let it go, I feel it's still there and when I'm angry, quite prominently so.

It's not a good thing, but you can't just ignore it. Justice needs to deal with this, otherwise it won't be accepted.

Fortunately this desire isn't very smart and can be tricked easily. If you paint something as terrible punishment and people see it as such, that is enough. Unlike, say, public safety, it doesn't actually need to be real to fully benefit society.