Re:Florida GOP consultant admits he worked with Guccifer 2.0...
by criddell on Friday May 26, 2017 @10:48AM
(#14424416)
I'm not a fan of the bad apples argument. The same reasoning is used by some to defend attacks on Muslims.
Re:Florida GOP consultant admits he worked with Guccifer 2.0...
by acdha on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:14AM
(#14424606)
There's a fairly key difference in the levels of opposition: you can easily find Muslims criticizing every extremist attack, rejecting the theology used to justify them, setting up education programs to reduce future recruitment, and working with law enforcement.
I think the strongest form of the bad apple argument comes not from the presence of a problem but rather the strength of counter-efforts.
Re:Florida GOP consultant admits he worked with Guccifer 2.0...
by _jal on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:37AM
(#14424798)
I probably wasn't clear. I'm not either. What I was alluding to was how common we hear a corruption of the phrase as a defense. "Just a few bad apples." Somehow the cautionary part of the cliche is disappeared.
If you look at individual actions only, it is easy to write things off. But I am not a prosecutor, and when we cross some critical mass of "isolated incidents", I start thinking the "bad apples" have spoiled the whole barrel, to actually use that cliche correctly for a change.
I'm sure there's a member or three of the Penn State frathouse recently in the news who weren't culpable in that kid's death, too.