Re:Wondering What Happened to Your Class Valedictorian? Not ...
by Fezzik on Wednesday May 24, 2017 @06:15PM
(#14413902)
I would just say the metric of "changing the world" the author is using is simply a bad metric. As you say, almost no one changes the world. The interesting part, to me, is that Valedictorians end up doing pretty darn well: "Of the 95 percent who went on to graduate college, their average GPA was 3.6, and by 1994, 60 percent had received a graduate degree. There was little debate that high school success predicted college success. Nearly 90 percent are now in professional careers with 40 percent in the highest tier jobs."
In short, being a Valedictorian in high-school is a great predictor of future success. The only perspective from which Valedictorians are not successful, given the data set, is from a holier-than-though mindset. Garbling that message by saying not every Valedictorian has moved mountains is... silly.
It gets worse because high schools aren't equally selective. There's probably plenty of tiny little high schools out in the Midwest or in other rural areas where 'valedictorian' means being the best-graded out of 20 or 50 kids, while on the other hand, at a magnet high school like Stuyvesant, half the school might be valedictorian level if they had gone elsewhere (but they can't all be the lone Stuy valedictorian).
Unless you've taken these into account, the rest of the discussion of grades selecting for Conscientiousness and conformity etc, while plausible, sound like just so many Just So stories.
(I have a similar issue with analyses of Hunter College Elementary School which speculate at great length about why its alumnis appear to be so disappointing, when as far as I can tell, the underperformance is exactly what one would expect from the unreliability of early-childhood IQ tests plus base rates: https://www.gwern.net/Statistical%20notes#genius-revisited-o... )