So basically they're eternally condemned to live in either a failed state or a harsh dictatorship?
Afghanistan used to be a normal country in the 70s by Middle Eastern standard. Not too different from Iran, Iraq, or Syria of those days.
It hasn't recovered for over 40 years.
Iraq doesn't seem like it will recover any time soon.
It seems quite possible to me that all this turmoil will lead to another local maximum that isn't much better, and perhaps even worse, than the previous one.