Re:Helping a Million Developers Exit Vim
by throwaway7645 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @07:52PM
(#14406489)
Is ":q!" really that crazy after 2 secs with Google?
Yes it is, if you are coming from a GUI life, start using the shell for the first time, and suddenly get thrown into some unnamed editor by git. :P
It breaks about every convention on editors and discoverability that you're used to.
Start GNU nano. It puts me in a position where typing edits the file I opened. It shows me the name of the program. It shows some keyboard shortcuts for interacting with the program. (Though for beginners the ^X syntax isn't obvious either).
Vim, doesn't give me any of that. I infrequently use vim and I still tend to open a file and start typing without hitting i first, because it's behaviour that's inconsistent with every single other editor I have ever used.
My worst memories of starting out with programming is doing a git merge or pull, then before the command was done, I'd start typing git push or... and then I got stuck in insert mode. This was after I had learned that :q och :wq! did the job, and I could not for the life of me figure out how to get out of insert mode.
Fun times.
Re:Helping a Million Developers Exit Vim
by throwaway7645 on Wednesday May 24, 2017 @06:53AM
(#14409015)
Or because every other editor you've had is inconsistent with Vim. It is dumb if people are being dumped there by Git. I guess if you try to use it and get stuck it is a lot easier to escape than if someone gets dumped there without even knowing where they are.
Memorize vi keystrokes is knowing the secret handshakes.
Able to Exit vim is finding the door to enlightenment.
If vi comes with an easy "back" button like all browsers, no-one will learn it. One needs to be trapped inside for a while to feel the power of the dark side.