News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by minimaxir on Sunday May 21, 2017 @02:14AM (#14385936)
Granted, "charging people as much as possible" is a basic tenet of microeconomics (another related one being pricing things according to the customer's willingness-to-pay). It's not even AI, just a first-derivative maximization.

Profit maximization is not inherently evil unless it's monopolistic. Which in the case of ride sharing, it isn't.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by bryanlarsen on Sunday May 21, 2017 @02:42AM (#14386001)
"not inherently evil"

The concept of the consumer surplus is the reason why capitalism is preferred over other economic systems such as feudalism or communism.

One price for all is a cornerstone of our social contract. Discarding it will place that contract in danger.

If all the profit in a trade goes to the robber barons, such trades will be rightly seen as unfair and calls for the revolution will become loud.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by bryanlarsen on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:01AM (#14386052)
Previous attempts at price discrimination have been transparent: senior's discounts, time or capacity based pricing, et cetera.

This is considerably different, being opaque. Once this gets out, everybody taking an Uber will have that nagging feeling in the back of their head, "was I ripped off this time?" And it'll make them think twice the next time they go to order one.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by thwarted on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:04AM (#14386063)
If someone gets the service they wanted/needed at a price they were willing to and agreed to pay, they weren't ripped off.
Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by sushid on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:22AM (#14386110)
Really? So you wouldn't think it was unfair that they charged you more because they guessed that your workplace or your rent price based on your trips? Or because your phone battery was almost dead in a location you're not normally at?

Think about it this way: You would probably pay a hospital your net worth if you had a child and he/she was seriously hurt and taken to a hospital. B would you think leveraging this information to take more money from you be "fair?"

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by thwarted on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:42AM (#14386183)
No, I wouldn't think it was unfair if they presented a price that was more because of <insert some reason here>, and then I decided not to pay it because I didn't think their service was was worth that price.

If you don't like what Uber is charging you, then don't take Uber. You can consider whatever constraints you like when determining the price you're willing to pay: convenience, time, cost, cleanliness, location, whathaveyou. Maybe you value your time less than the cost of an Uber, so you can then walk to your destination. You ripped off Uber then by using your two perfectly good feet, and showed those capitalist fatcats by not even using their service!

The comparison to a serious hurt child is not an appropriate comparison (also, "think of the children!"), because the service is not fungible in that case.

Is someone going to show up and make the same arguments for why people with higher incomes shouldn't pay higher taxes? If there's nothing wrong with progressive taxation, then there's nothing wrong with progressive pricing, and the only difference is that you're forced the pay taxes while you're not forced to purchase services from any given vendor.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by sushid on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @05:01PM (#14405305)
First, you're basing your argument on a mistaken premise that progressive taxation is okay. Second, it's relatively clear that you're going to be paying a certain rate in taxes, whereas your Uber prices can now have a huge, unforeseen jump in pricing because <insert personal reason here>. It's the difference between knowing you have to pay a higher rate because you're not a "Shopper's club member" vs. having an arbitrary fee added to your grocery at checkout because you're carrying a Louis Vuitton bag.

And I'm not arguing this from a purely economics perspective. Yes, I know discriminatory pricing has its place in our society today and yes, I know it's profit maximizing, "fair," etc. But what's different here is that unlike airlines that have an algorithm deciding the same price for anyone buying that seat at that particular time, Uber can discriminate against you for very personal reasons, or general reasons that can discriminate against the racial makeup of a neighborhood, the disabled, etc.

Hats off to your sense of duty to capitalism that'd make Milton Friedman proud, but the world doesn't work like an Econ 101 textbook. If Uber's profit maximizing algorithm is discriminatory against protected classes, it's illegal. If it's profit maximizing by overcharging people lulled into usage due to habit, dying phones, etc. it's still predatory.

P.S. regarding your "think of the children" critique, I'm simply offering a direct counterexample to your "whatever price you pay and agree to == not getting ripped off." According to you, it does seem like you can be ripped off after all, even at a price you were willing to pay.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by yorwba on Sunday May 21, 2017 @04:12AM (#14386287)
I think this crucially depends on how much influence both parties have over their respective situations.

In the hospital example, if you had a choice of several hospitals at different price points and chose the more expensive one, then it is fair of them to demand the price they quoted upfront.

Likewise, if the hospital needs the money just to cover the expenses incurred in trying to save the child, the price is fair as well.

But if they have a choice and you don't, they are unfairly abusing the situation. (See also: Martin Shkreli jacking up the price on a drug exclusively manufactured by his company.)

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by bryanlarsen on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:11AM (#14386081)
Haven't you heard anybody rant for hours about how gas stations raise their prices on the weekends, or some sort of similar rant?

People act very emotionally to the idea that someone else got a better deal than they did.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by thwarted on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:23AM (#14386118)
Yes, and those people didn't get ripped off, they are just uninformed ranters. They could have just as well purchased their gas at a low-price time, especially since they KNOW (proven by their ranting) the prices change.

It could just as well be that the "higher, weekend" price is the "normal price" and the weekday price is the "deal, sale" price.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by open_bear on Sunday May 21, 2017 @01:13PM (#14388133)
Airlines have been ripping customers for years. Ever tried to search for tickets while in incognito mode? Prices will most likely be lower, because there is no tracking information that can tell the airline "this person can pay more".
Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by golergka on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:21AM (#14386107)
> One price for all is a cornerstone of our social contract. Discarding it will place that contract in danger.

That is a very strange statement - could you explain how did you come to such a conclusion?

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by bryanlarsen on Sunday May 21, 2017 @06:26PM (#14389570)
When commodities are traded, the price is set at the marginal cost, which is usually only slightly higher than the actual cost. So the consumer makes much more "profit" on each trade than the producers do. So even though capitalism is seen as highly unfair, it's tolerated -- the poor and the middle class do better than they would under communism or feudalism or anything else.

But if the producer is able to capture the surplus, the already rich capture all of the profit, and the system becomes much less balanced, the poor & middle class start feeling even more exploited by the rich. They decide that it's better to have a small pie divided evenly than to just have the crumbs from a large pie, and start voting in candidates who promise to dismantle trade deals, tax the rich, et cetera.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by willart4food on Sunday May 21, 2017 @02:59AM (#14386047)
and yet "variable pricing" has been happening since ever even in low-tech offline business. Need your house painted and live in a "better" neighborhood? You'll pay more.

Ever heard of the "Tesla Tax" for people installing the outlet needed to charge their Tesla?

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by tylerhou on Sunday May 21, 2017 @02:58AM (#14386043)
>One price for all is a cornerstone of our social contract. Discarding it will place that contract in danger.

...but we've had price discrimination for decades in the form of coupons, airplane tickets, and senior discounts. I don't see a particularly loud revolution, at least where I live.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by bryanlarsen on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:06AM (#14386070)
Airlines are one of the most hated industries, seen much good press about United.

And their price discrimination is fairly transparent, it's the opaque discrimination that gets people ranting. Nobody likes being ripped off.

Coupons & senior discounts are tolerated both because they're transparent and everybody can or will be able to use them.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by dnautics on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:49AM (#14386215)
No, capitalism is preferred over feudalism and communism because it maximizes individual agency. It may be difficult because you might have a hard time eating, but you can always quit working in capitalism without worrying about the state punishing you.
Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by achille on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:09AM (#14386078)
Yes, it makes mathematical sense, but it feels bad at a visceral, gut level. From personal experience, when visiting some countries, taxis would quote 2x or 3x the standard fare just because they saw I was clearly a tourist.

This is essentially the same, except there isn't even an option for haggling.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by golergka on Sunday May 21, 2017 @03:22AM (#14386111)
> it feels bad at a visceral, gut level

Using 'visceral, gut level' as a guide for ethics usually leads to ugly consequences.

Re:Uber Is Using AI to Charge People as Much as Possible for... by achille on Sunday May 21, 2017 @04:11AM (#14386283)
Not at all. I would argue the opposite. Ignoring it leads to ugly consequences. It's why we got Trump. For a lot of people, the idea of illegal immigrants cutting in line to get to the US, feels unfair and they took the bait.

Same thing here. Is it fair for me to get charged more than the next person for the same trip? Everyone understands the feeling of unfairness (even dogs [1]). Humans don't make perfect mathematical choices, which is why the entire field of behavioral economics exists, and it's why Uber will be eventually forced to provide even pricing, whether they like it or not.

[1] - http://www.pnas.org/content/106/1/340.full