News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by jerf on Thursday June 17, 2010 @12:05AM (#1437908)
"Here's the thing: in all of your examples, you're giving me a choice that I have no right to make."

Ah, but here's the kicker: When it comes to valuing things, you can't help but choose. If you refuse to choose between the life of your $FAVORITE_PERSON and the destruction of the Sistene Chapel, then you have chosen whatever consequences arise when you refuse to choose.

The important thing is not the specifics at stake, which are quite silly here, but the fact that you have to choose. You can't not. You don't get to not choose because it's "arrogant" to choose. You don't get to not choose because "it's hard". You have to choose. Choosing to "not choose" is a choice and in whatever situation your are in constitutes some choice itself.

People in the real world have literally and truly faced the choice of which of their children they will save. They chose something. I imagine a non-trivial number of them were paralyzed by the logic you are applying and chose poorly as a result.

It may help if you realize that a dollar isn't just a dollar, and once you start talking about millions or billions of them the character of a dollar changes in ways that far too few people realize. A dollar is blood, sweat, tears, time spent working instead of with one's family, a finite and characterizable risk of death in the aggregate, indeed, lifeblood itself converted into currency. Taking a billion of them out of an economy is to doom people to fractionally shorter lives, for marginal people to be lost, and a lot of other very serious things much more important than whether Johnny gets to buy a videogame this week. The extinction of a species and ten billion dollars are far more comparable than you might care to admit, not because you overvalue the species, but because you undervalue the dollars. They're not just scores in a game. They're human life.

(In other news, I consider white collar crime grotesquely under punished. Bernie Madoff may not have killed a man, but the damage he did in the aggregate adds up to at least one murder, in my book. He did not steal dollars, he stole life.)

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by sprout on Thursday June 17, 2010 @12:58AM (#1437987)
I agree with you in general, but I'm not so sure when we look at something like Madoff where money literally vanishes. That money, as you say, represents an actual value that did not actually vanish. It's rather hard to say where it went, but it's unclear that there's a net drop in value for humanity.

This could in a certain sense be a case where the broken window fallacy actually holds up to scrutiny. Since the money is merely symbolic, no value is actually lost, merely shifted. People are adversely affected, but if they are spurred to create more value, it's plausible that the net benefit is positive to society.

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by jerf on Thursday June 17, 2010 @10:04AM (#1438928)
There is, if nothing else, the opportunity cost of where that money could have been productively invested instead of wasted to no effect.

Money and wealth aren't directly connected (IMHO a critical and underrated aspect of understanding real-world economics), and it is true that money rarely justs evaporates. Wealth can, though, and even merely inefficiently applying money can build up to an opportunity cost. There were better things to do with that money than to spend effort making it, then piss it away.

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by houseabsolute on Thursday June 17, 2010 @01:01AM (#1437990)
You're right. It was a consumption transfer away from Madoff's victims and to Madoff and his beneficiaries (with some blow-off to the rest of the economy when Madoff lost money in bad investments). Although there is some value lost whenever anyone invests in unproductive activities, because investment is an encouragement to those inefficient activities.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by billswift on Thursday June 17, 2010 @01:25AM (#1438031)
Actually most of the money Madoff took in went right back out to his victims - that's how Ponzi schemes work.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by houseabsolute on Thursday June 17, 2010 @01:54AM (#1438090)
Theoretically, that would mean that none of the victims were defrauded of any money, or the ones that received money fraudulently could conceivably be forced to return it. But that's not my understanding of what has happened.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by billswift on Thursday June 17, 2010 @03:54AM (#1438250)
Actually, the earlier "victims" tend to make out pretty well, especially in the beginning. Later victims purely lost out. And Madoff certainly "skimmed" enough to live pretty well on.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by nradov on Friday June 18, 2010 @02:30AM (#1441507)
Most of the Madoff money didn't "vanish", it never existed in the first place. He just made up numbers and sent them out on account statements. That money didn't go anywhere since it wasn't actually money to begin with.