Re:Video Messages and Telescope on Telegram
by egypturnash on Friday May 19, 2017 @12:40PM
(#14377293)
Can you finally use the same Signal sign in on more than one device at once now? That was one of the things that drove me nuts about it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Signal is not great on multiple devices (it works, but not always seamlessly), but there's a reason for that: Signal is also generating virtually no serverside metadata. There's a real, practical security win for the inconvenience it's generating for people who want multi-device messaging.
Compare that to Wire, which has much more convenient multi-device support, but accomplishes that at the expense of keeping the entire active graph of communicating Wire users in plaintext in their servers on AWS.
Both Wire and WhatsApp (which have comparable security models with some marginal tradeoffs --- WhatsApp metadata is in Facebook's custody, which is not great, but Wire doesn't have Facebook's extremely competent and well-resourced security team) are reasonable choices for secure messengers.
Telegram is not.
Thanks for pointing out the tradeoffs of Wire and Signal so forthrightly. I would not have been able to describe the difference so clearly.
Re:Video Messages and Telescope on Telegram
by SparkyMcUnicorn on Friday May 19, 2017 @12:54PM
(#14377435)
Yes. I continue conversations from my phone -> computer (and vice versa) every day.
This is the main reason I won't leave Telegram. I don't need perfect privacy, I've never seen any reports of Telegram actually being breached, and I use four different devices over the course of my day. Each one has a fully functioning Telegram client.