* As you mentioned, the Prez' authority is (mostly) limited to the US. I say "mostly" because the US has been known to exert economic and even military pressure on other countries that didn't toe the line of US interests. Shutting down the US corner of the Internet would take about 13% of worldwide Internet _users_ offline; in terms of infrastructure and services, I'd wager it would be lots more. Consider that Google, Yahoo, MSN and lots of other globally significant sites are US based.
* Something else to consider: Who runs the DNS root servers? Isn't internic run by a US company? In theory, DNS is redundant; in practice, I think loss of the root servers would kick up a lot of disturbance. AFAIK the Internet would be crippled for most intents and purposes without DNS.
Granted their caches will run stale fairly quickly but they won't be inoperable.
I don't know if the president could shut down the internet or not, but I'd like to see him try. That would be all kinds of crazy fun.
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/03/presidents-v...
For the record, even if every ISP in the US agreed to shut down, no the rest of the world would not be "shut down", except for US-based services going off the air, or to the extent that they house their services on US-based servers.
The origin of the Internet lies exactly in the requirement that it be "self-healing". You can read an early history here:
http://zitthere.com/tech/networks/internet/inet-hist.html