News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is a college degree still worth it? by patio11 on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @01:39PM (#1436336)
A client is currently paying me a rather substantial amount of money to come up with an authoritatively presented answer to this question, using BLS data and some programming. (It figures that the number crunching would take one week and the presentation layer would take three. sigh)

Spoiler: College degrees are still worth it. Some are rather substantially more worth it than others. If you feel yours isn't, you almost certainly aren't majored in engineering or (certain flavors of) geology.

Re:Is a college degree still worth it? by jerf on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @02:13PM (#1436461)
If it is possible to share the results with us, I'd like to see it when you are done. I recognize that may not be possible. I think I have a good bead on the general results, but specifics are nice, and concrete charts could even be helpful for talking to college-bound seniors about what it is they need to be doing in a way that "here, let me share my intuitions" aren't.
Re:Is a college degree still worth it? by patio11 on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @08:02PM (#1437464)
Thanks Jerf. They've previously indicated that they'd be thrilled to have me show it off, and I'd be happy to write a "how I built this" or something for my blog linking to the results.

Fair warning: it is marketing material, in much the same sense that one of the NYT's data visualizations is marketing, except they have a business model which benefits in a more direct fashion than the NYT does.

Re:Is a college degree still worth it? by InclinedPlane on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @02:45PM (#1436567)
This runs into a correlation/causation problem though. The sort of people who are interested and dedicated enough in a subject to dedicate N years of their life and a significant amount of money to pursue a college degree in that major may also have the drive to succeed in their chosen field regardless of degree (or to pursue education in other ways). I doubt this is entirely true, but it's an important effect to keep in mind.
Re:Is a college degree still worth it? by carbocation on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @01:52PM (#1436390)
I agree with you based on my intuition. I want to make a point that's not even a quibble with what you're doing (since you're working within fixed constraints) but I feel is worth raising anyways.

The BLS data that I'm familiar with are not granular enough to decisively reach the conclusion that a college degree is still worth it. For example, the BLS data do not allow you to even begin to guess if colleges are merely admitting people who could have directly entered High Paying Job X even had they not attended college.

Take Princeton, for example. Does a Princeton degree add income potential, or is it simply the case that people who get into Princeton are so smart that they have lots of income potential? The only way to conclusively know this is to identify people who were admitted to Princeton (and thus met their entry criteria) but decided not to go to college at all. (Even then, there would be selection bias here, since those choosing not to attend probably differ qualitatively from those who attended.) Then, look at standardized lifetime earnings of both cohorts. Do Princeton grads do better than Princeton admits who decided to forgo college?

The best test would be a randomized controlled trial but... heh... that's just not going to happen since there's likely harm without likely benefit if you're in the no-college cohort.

Re:Is a college degree still worth it? by euroclydon on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @02:16PM (#1436473)
Good points, but your just speaking about innate talent regardless of a college degree. You're forgetting family and social connections regardless of talent or a degree.
Re:Is a college degree still worth it? by carbocation on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @02:49PM (#1436581)
True! Although the methods I'm proposing would capture those, too. (Without quantifying connections and family, the reason why wouldn't be captured, but the difference itself would be.)