But to be cost-competitive with fracked methane, I'm pretty sure we're going to need some heavily genetically-engineered strains of algae, growing in artificial forests of pipes.
The irony is that algae can be used to clean up fracking wastewater, so it makes methane production cheaper as it competes.
The promise of syntetic fossil fuels from things like water and CO2 is that you don't need a lot of land, you just need energy, and that energy can be renewable.
So far the process to do this involves a lot of messy intermediate steps, like hundreds of millions of years and enormous pressure in the mantle of the Earth.
http://www.audi.com/corporate/en/corporate-responsibility/we...
(mentioned on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabatier_reaction)
Who knows what the economics really are, but they don't sound dire.
We need energy in portable forms (and have other uses for hydrocarbons). Getting that energy from clean sources and storing it with atmospheric CO2 is better than burning fossil sources of energy.