1. cases where the compiler explicitly recognizes a certain permutation of compilation-state as matching some pattern for what the standard calls "undefined behavior"—and then is unconstrained as to what it does in response, but indeed does something in response to detecting that state;
2. cases where the compiler has no compile-time static-analysis approach available for detecting a certain edge-case (e.g. integer overflow), and, further, is inhibited by the standard from generating code to detect that edge-case at runtime either; so the compiler is forced to leave the response to that condition either up to the programmer to explicitly handle, or up to the target architecture to respond to however it likes when it happens.
It's clear to me that undefined behavior of the second class is sort of just part of what C "is": a language where the complexity-classes of all the primitives [well, except FP math] are constrained at compile-time, so a line of code that's O(1) on one arch won't get runtime-polyfilled into being O(N) on another in order to "make the arch sane."
But my question, then, is this: would it break anything about support for the "not C machine" architectures, if the standard said that everything falling into the first class—explicit undefined behavior—was instead defined behavior, defined as "abort compilation"?
Well you're in luck, since gcc -Werror when used with many of its -W flags will do precisely that.
You guys should read the minutes of committee discussions and position papers. "undefined behavior" is not something introduced to make programmers' lives hard!
Also look at IEEE734 which does define things to an incredible degree -- it's extremely hard to use (as it needed to be!). It's one of the very best standards of all time, and still has, yes, undefined behavior.
That's not lucky; I'd argue it's the opposite. An ecosystem built around compilers that default to not using -Werror (or rather: `-Werror=pedantic -pedantic-errors`) is an ecosystem that encourages people to write code that relies on the optimizations compilers make in response to undefined behavior. Which, undoubtedly, "makes [maintenance] programmers' lives hard," when they change one little thing and suddenly the code gets 10x slower because now e.g. a dead loop isn't being elided.
If all compilers defaulted to something like `-Werror=pedantic -pedantic-errors`—and it was highly discouraged to turn those flags off—then jumping in to contribute to a portable, sprawling codebase would be infinitely simpler, because the codebase would have been written in a far more rigorous way up to that point.
Sunlight is the best disinfectant—so why do we allow our compiler-vendors to default the lights to off?
"You may have thought you were checking for overflow here, but technically speaking the result of that operation could be undefined, therefore this code could do literally anything, or nothing. So I'll just remove it all. Congratulations, now it runs faster!"
I honestly hadn't realized that was a controversial view. Doesn't almost everyone dislike that? Are there a lot of C programmers who are happy to accept that risk in exchange for slightly better optimization?
But in the last few years I've read many, many articles about problems that crop up when optimizing C compilers do weird things to reasonable-looking code, citing "undefined behavior" as an excuse. I can't say for sure if I've hit issues like that myself, but I've certainly used libraries that have.
Maybe the problem lies squarely with the compiler vendors, but the language spec enables them.
If the behaviour is undefined then the code is broken. Programmers need to learn the language instead of putting together hail mary code expecting it to somehow work in spite of the language specifically telling them that they should not expect any defined behavior out of it.
People who whine about undefined behavior are like kids who insist in jamming their fingers in a electric socket and whine when they get a shock.
Why do you think there is undefined behavior? Because committee members are lazy?
Not every machine is a C machine (PDP-11). I used to program machines with bytes that could range from 1-36 bits (these are older than the PDP-7/PDP-11 that C was designed for). A joy to program, but the C model did not apply. You may consider these architectures obsolete, and they are, but many decisions in the design of IP, UDP and TCP (and some higher level protocols) still reflect these machines.
Early C standardization efforts bent backwards to support the architectures committee members cared about. Some constraints (undef behavior etc) were removed in later standards (though the C++ committee is more aggressive in this regard than the C committee).
And you well could argue that C's tight coupling to the architecture of the PDP-11 and the programming standards of the 70s holds back CPU design. Many of these undefined areas are places where compilers have the opportunity to take advantage of CPU features (e.g. vector hardware).
The committee mailing list and other discussions are open -- have a read. And if you feel strongly you can even join the committee.