News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by woodruffw on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @10:10PM (#14355050)
Government communications should eventually be made public, but they probably shouldn't always be initially or immediately public.

Whistleblowing and legal affairs come to mind -- whistleblowers need to feel secure in order to report misdeeds, and even elected officials have attorney privileges.

Those certainly aren't the only cases, but they're two examples where open probably isn't the right default for communications.

Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by maxerickson on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @10:43PM (#14355218)
Short of mandating life recorders, there is reason to strike a balance between publishing what they say and letting them work without obsessing over the future publication of what they say.
Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by fao_ on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @05:21AM (#14356805)
Them obsessing about the future publication of their comments makes them think more about what they say, and more about how the impact will affect the future and their future career. It gives them a mooring post to understand how acting in the interest of the people relates to them. IMO it is only really a good thing.
Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by maxerickson on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @09:19AM (#14358098)
I think this is a very optimistic and generous view of humanity.

Even with perfect life recorders I think you'd end up with a moribund apparatus playing 5 dimensional tic tac toe (that is, sensible people would call for letting them turn the damn things off whenever they wanted to).

Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by jonwachob91 on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @07:32AM (#14357426)
No it doesn't. It gives them the motivation to find ways of communicating off the record.
Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by fao_ on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @09:03AM (#14357985)
That's like saying locks give burglars motivation to find ways of getting in, other than doors. Sure it does, but that doesn't mean that we should suddenly get rid of locks. Indeed, many of us take the opposite tack, and install security alarms and cameras to intentionally lock down the rest of the house.

Governors, Politicians, etc. are public servants. They are not there for their own good, they are there to follow the law, and the serve the interests of their constituents, and only that. Therefore it stands to reason that any communications they have with other officials, about official business, should be recorded as it is a matter of public record. It stops "he said she said" disputes. It helps us know about underhanded deals, unfair advantages, and many of the other things that people do when given such powers with no oversight.

Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by mtgx on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @05:34AM (#14356866)
I believe Signal can already deal with this, but the government would probably have to be forced by law to do it in a more explicit way.

Like, they can use self-disappearing messages, but all messages are automatically archived and encrypted with a pre-set password. I guess this could still open the data to being stolen if the password is discovered, but I don't really see any other solution to making both self-disappearing messages and FOIA requests working at the same time.

Re:U.S. Senate staff can now use Signal by bpchaps on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @11:27PM (#14355403)
Agreed, but it's very unlikely to happen any time soon, though there are definitely things that can be done.

If anyone wants to help out in collecting government communications using FOIA, please let me know. It's surprisingly easy to get bulk communications data of cities, though it ends up being very time consuming with everything considered. I could definitely use the help, especially with a project beyond the city level that started just this week.

Here's [1] an example of a dataset of ~2mo of email meta - about six million emails - I recently received from Houston, TX. (Thanks to Jeff Reichman at januaryadvisors.com for cleaning the data up!)

[1] https://data.world/sketchcity/city-of-houston-email-metadata...