Re:Scientists Achieve Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communic...
by gus_massa on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:57PM
(#14346576)
This is usual. I don't know why they explained it here. [1]
This result was published in a peer review journal. It means that two or three experts read the article and found no evident flaw and think that it has enough details to make the experiment in another laboratory [2]. They didn't go to the laboratory and unbolted every piece to double check the setup, or make a copy in their own laboratory to check the experiment. So until two or three more laboratories try this and a few variations, this is still doubtful, but there is a good chance that this is true.
[2] Usually the papers don't have enough information. You have to guess and email the authors and cross your fingers to reproduce the result.
[1] My guess is that they explained this because the result is very unintuitive.
Re:Scientists Achieve Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communic...
by dflock on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:26PM
(#14346944)
As you sort of imply in your second footnote, "has enough details to make the experiment in another laboratory" often _isn't_ a requirement to pass peer review, sadly.
Re:Scientists Achieve Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communic...
by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @04:11AM
(#14348111)
It's frequently a loose requirement; trouble is to know how much information is necessary to replicate, you typically have to do the actual replication (and iterate with authors over details). Not to mention that journals tend to dislike overly long papers.
Re:Scientists Achieve Direct Counterfactual Quantum Communic...
by deepsun on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:40PM
(#14346772)
That's probably why it's included in "fakenews" category on
https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts
Article: "The results will now need to be verified by external researchers to make sure what the researchers saw was a true example of counterfactual quantum communication."
Okay then