News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by manicdee on Monday May 15, 2017 @07:41PM (#14346193)
Highly skilled technical employees cost time and money to build/train.

People who don't train for highly skilled jobs typically do not have the money or the support infrastructure required for that training.

This gets compounded when a low skilled worker finds themselves between jobs: they now have the same constraints but also need to find money quickly to service debt such as rent or home loan.

When you describe as "mismatch" what is a bona fide shortage, you are completely ignoring the structure of society which leads to this problem: education is a profit industry, at cost to the student. Industry has few apprenticeships or cadet ships available. Industry doesn't want to train the good people ("matches") to become skilled the way industry wants.

Once the inividual has been trained, industry will trip over themselves to hire or poach them.

So industry doesn't want to pay for training even though they can afford it, the individual can't afford training even though they want it.

If only there was a way to provide training for highly skilled roles in such a way that all industry pays for the training and the individual only shoulders the time costs.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by pasquinelli on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:07PM (#14346631)
I agree with you but at the same time, if there was a bona fide shortage of labor then wouldn't industry be training people?
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by Terr_ on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:17PM (#14346676)
> then wouldn't industry be training people?

Ideally, but there's also a sort of prisoner's-dilemma [0] going on, where if company A trains well and company B doesn't but puts the budget into wages, people will train at A and then leave for B higher pay.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by pasquinelli on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @01:04AM (#14347481)
If there's actually a labor shortage, B will starve for want of labor. Labor isn't just a cost, it's an investment, and the kind of loyalty you'd get by training someone without a lot of prospects in a high demand field for free shouldn't be ignored.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by Terr_ on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @02:25AM (#14347755)
> If there's actually a labor shortage, B will starve for want of labor.

B is able to offer higher salaries.

Yes, employee loyalty is a thing, but it's also hard to justify to MBA-types and is softer when the employees are in demand.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by Glyptodon on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:31PM (#14346733)
Maybe they don't believe there's enough demand and/or economic growth to justify the investment considering its risks and expenses?

If given a choice between paying for 6 months of training, or 6 months of waiting for the perfect candidate, waiting is much cheaper. In fact, the longer training takes and the more valuable the trainee at the end (the more demand for the trainee from competitors, essentially), I would guess the less likely businesses are to want to foot the bill. Likewise, training means you have to pay/contract so as to insure that there's not a high risk of a trainee being sniped.

On the demand/economic growth angle, witness all the large corporations hoarding record amounts of cash. It seems like many businesses recognize that disposable income is fairly well soaked - I think a general perception is that there's not enough disposable income to risk much investment in new products/industries unless they somehow clearly cannibalize from an existing market segment or specifically target upper incomes (and it takes a lot for something targeting upper incomes to be viable enough to not be boutique).

Anyway, this is mostly speculation on my part.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by pasquinelli on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @01:08AM (#14347499)
"If given a choice between paying for 6 months of training, or 6 months of waiting for the perfect candidate, waiting is much cheaper."

Fair enough, but then this is not a labor shortage. An employee makes their boss money. In a labor shortage, waiting for the perfect candidate is choosing to lose money.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by rjblackman on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @03:37AM (#14347982)
it is also likely at the end of the training the employee is more valuable to the company than to the competitors (since they know the culture and technology), so in order to keep them from moving to a competitor they should pay more than a competitor would.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by wolfgke on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:20PM (#14346399)
> Once the inividual has been trained, industry will trip over themselves to hire or poach them.

Why not simply create employment contracts that bind the respective apprentice/employee to the company, say, for 5 or 7 years (or whatever) if they fear that the employee will be poached?

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thedufer on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:26PM (#14346438)
I suspect such a contract would be unenforceable in most first world countries. It certainly would be in the US, which is not exactly a paragon of worker protections.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @09:06AM (#14349197)
I doubt that. There is some sort of program like that in Norway. Im still a bit fuzzy on the actual details, but the employer sends you to appropriate schooling - the dude I knew went 2 days a week, one was a paid workday and the other was on his time. He had to pass the tests and agree to work there for x time, otherwise pay back the training costs. He's left with a valid, transferrable degree to other similar places - the degree would be similar to an associates.

Another solution I've seen was in the US. Some pharmacies will train pharmacy technicians and incur the expenses themselves. The tech license, however, is only good so long as they are employed at that company. (folks can pay for such training on their own dime, which can transfer between employers).

And yet a third solution: I looked into becoming an electrician in the late 90's (in the US, specifically Indiana). The local electricians union provided schooling and training, no cost to you, so long as you stayed with the union employment for something like 4-5 years lest you pay back the schooling costs. I'm pretty sure the local plumber's union did something similar.

Both countries have methods of reclaiming such money - the court systems. Both can withhold money from your paycheck for such things as well, if you don't pay. In the US, that amount is something like 25% of your paycheck, so long as you are left with 30 hours wages at minimum wage. In addition, they can likely take away any professional licenses you obtained until you pay it back.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by chii on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:45PM (#14346528)
why would it be unenforceable? it's not like you can't leave (indentured servitude). it's just that if you choose to leave before your term is up, you have to pay back the training cost pro-rata, and that sound very reasonable.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by IanCal on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:12PM (#14346656)
> . it's just that if you choose to leave before your term is up, you have to pay back the training cost pro-rata, and that sound very reasonable.

This is pretty common [edit - in the UK], and there are distinctions made in law to stop this being abused (e.g. "if you leave you owe us a million for the basic training cost")

[context, liquidated damages clauses are OK in an employment contract, penalty clauses are not]

> Case law has clarified that in order for a clause to be a liquidated damages provision rather than a penalty, it must be a genuine reflection of an employer’s pre-estimate of loss that it is likely to suffer if the employee breaches that provision. If an employer is unable to quantify the exact loss that would be suffered, a best guess of the likely loss would be satisfactory. - See more at: http://rosenblatt-law.co.uk/bulletins/are-repayment-provisio...

[snip]

> The key to a repayment sum being regarded as a genuine pre-estimate of loss appears to be that the sum specified must be compensatory and not ‘in terroreum’ or simply a deterrent to breaching the contract - See more at: http://rosenblatt-law.co.uk/bulletins/are-repayment-provisio...

http://rosenblatt-law.co.uk/bulletins/are-repayment-provisio...

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by dikdik on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:28PM (#14346951)
Companies don't want to deal with being debt collectors is what this comes down to.

My last job paid for a good portion of my masters, every time I was reimbursed for tutition there was a set amount of time I had to still be with the company or I had to repay a certain amount.

Ended up leaving before finishing my degree due to really hating the company, I was prepared to hand back 15k, but they never even bothered asking for it. Same thing happened to a coworker of mine, though it was substantially less money in that case.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thedufer on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:20PM (#14346690)
Just having to pay for the training is not what the person I responded to seemed to be suggesting (it sounds like indentured servitude was exactly what was being proposed, in fact). That is, as others have mentioned, reasonably common, and apparently not enough to solve the problem if companies still refuse to provide training.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by tudorconstantin on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:50PM (#14347251)
You don't leave, you simply start doing a lousy job so the employer has to fire you.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by joslin01 on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:55PM (#14346570)
I signed a contract like that. They were paranoid I was going to jump ship during a critical time, so gave me a bonus under condition that if I leave company before X months, I would be forced to pay back bonus. Not sure if it's enforceable, but I didn't leave.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by JCharante on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @03:37AM (#14347985)
I've heard Amazon gives out bonuses with those conditions, so I'd guess it's enforceable.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by imron on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:58PM (#14346581)
Yes, I'm sure such a system would never be abused. /s