Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by ericras on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:36PM
(#14338524)
This piece does a fairly good job of presenting the conservative point of view: that there are mountains of waste in government to cut rather than hike taxes. I agree with that perspective.
Unfortunately, as we've seen from Republican-led governments operating under this Grover Norquist-esque model for thirty years, the beast never starves. In Washington DC they print money to offset deficits. Instead of cutting waste, the libraries and the parks are closed.
There's still a great desire out there for responsible government that can operate efficiently. That can keep the libraries open by trimming bureaucratic waste rather than asking for more money. Probably will always be a pipe dream.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Spooky23 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:43PM
(#14338558)
I've worked in government in a variety of capacities. The stereotypical waste that is typically cooked up in a drop in the bucket.
Waste that you get from the privatization efforts are an order of magnitude more expensive. Unfortunately, the people in policy positions today are clueless... voting no doesn't fix anything.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by brohoolio on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:46PM
(#14338579)
My local government is really transparent about the budget, where it's going. They've been running really lean since the great recession. It's really interesting to see how they spend money. There are couple programs I question, but for the most part they do an excellent job. I will say sometimes a few years after these programs are implemented I'm generally a fan.
I understand the drive to make government more efficient, run better, but I'm not sure if that's the goal of the current conservative movement. At least here in Michigan the state government under republican control has caused all sorts of issues, like the Flint water crisis.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by ashark on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:59PM
(#14338626)
A couple of my friends are in low-level positions with the state government. At least in their cases, I can say that their offices run so lean that cost-cutting attempts from higher up just lead to worse service and conflicting (or outright illegal) directives, which encourage rule-breaking of a sort that is sure to eventually bite them in the ass in expensive ways.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Clubber on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:05PM
(#14338660)
The beast never starves because the GOP feeds it when it's theirs. They complained endlessly about the debt, but once they are in power, they are proposing the largest tax cut we've probably every seen. It's all a lie.
For what it's worth, I'm all for reigning in government spending and power. Sounds like we are ratcheting up another drug war.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by slackingoff2017 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:48PM
(#14338586)
The problem with cutting costs is that nobody agrees on what should get cut. Everyone has their district and it's pet projects.
The best way I've seen it done is to just slash everything by the same amount. Sadly this results in things like closing libraries.
Nobody agrees on what's waste and what isn't. If everyone agreed that X was a big waste of money it wouldn't exist, so we're stuck with a system where every dollar goes to a thing somebody cares about
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by scarface74 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:15PM
(#14338700)
I can understand the idea of worrying about government waste at the federal level or even the state level, but you can see exactly where your taxes go at the local level and especially in small towns, the politicians aren't some remote out of touch folks that you never see. I moved away from my hometown of about 100,000 people 20 years ago, but I could probably get in touch with most of the politicians there through family connections. In fact, the current mayor is the mother of one of my best friends. I go to her house almost every Christmas to see my friend.
On top of that, a lot of times like in the case of the library, you know exactly where the tax increases are going.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by anigbrowl on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:55PM
(#14338611)
But why is it that when conservatives are in government they go for the easy targets instead of tackling the structural problems? There are lots of ideas in conservative philosophy that are superficially very attractive and that I'd like to agree with, but far fewer examples of conservative governance bringing down costs while maintaining or improving service levels.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:47PM
(#14338810)
For the same reason that when liberals are in government they give you a right-wing healthcare bill and expand 2 wars to 7. Because as the now infamous Princeton study demonstrated, Congress doesn't care what voters want. http://www.upworthy.com/20-years-of-data-reveals-that-congre...
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:10AM
(#14339102)
You specifically said when conservatives are in government, not conservative voters. The answer to your question is that the people in government, regardless of whether they campaigned as conservative or liberal, do not care one iota about what the voters who put them in office want.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @08:03AM
(#14348892)
I provided a reference. What more do you want? Go look at the provided data. It doesn't matter whether liberals or conservatives hold power. Government doesn't do liberal or conservative things. It does whatever the wealthy want. If that happens to appear conservative or liberal on the outside that's purely incidental.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @05:28PM
(#14353448)
You're totally entitled to that opinion and I myself largely agree with public choice theory, but the post to which I responded began thus:
This piece does a fairly good job of presenting the conservative point of view: that there are mountains of waste in government to cut rather than hike taxes. I agree with that perspective.
And it was that agreement with conservatism as a political philosophy that I asked to explore. It's not that your opinion is invalid, but that it is unresponsive to the question that was asked. I am not interested in having an argument with you, I'm interested in knowing where that other person was coming from.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @08:05AM
(#14348901)
Geez, I even provided a reference demonstrating that both sides of the aisle have the same exact behavior of ignoring both their perceived ideologies and what voters want.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by glangdale on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:30PM
(#14338751)
Which parts of government spending do you consider 'waste', and what proportion of government spending do they add up to? If they are 'mountains' of waste they should be easy to identify, and if you have such a strongly held viewpoint on it, you should also have plenty of evidence.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:44PM
(#14338800)
It's not as simple as saying a given program is a waste. The government procurement system is incredibly wasteful. Instead of actually going with the lowest bidder they intentionally order parts from lots of different Congressional districts. Otherwise funding won't get approved. A prime example of what happens when you can escape government procurement is SpaceX.
Beyond that there's huge obvious ones that come along all the time like the F22s we keep buying more of even though the military doesn't want them. This of course is a jobs program for engineers and a way to again funnel money into the districts which all these random parts are procured.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Frondo on Sunday May 14, 2017 @11:53PM
(#14339039)
Please distinguish between federal-level procurement and state and local procurement.
"Instead of actually going with the lowest bidder .. " In many states, it's law that they must go with the lowest bidder. This often causes problems because that lowest bidder delivers shoddy work that leads to eventual cost overruns--going with the "best value" instead of "lowest price" would reward companies that could meet both cost AND quality expectations. It'd also more closely reflect private sector considerations if those laws were changed; a private company can spend more for higher quality and get the long-term benefit of that quality deliverable, and that's a trade-off and decision that's simply taken away from state/local procurement professionals.
State and local procurement tends to run pretty lean, and tends to be pretty accountable. All this stuff is public record, and local papers will often cull through that stuff looking for juicy nuggets. The relative rarity of public purchasing scandals, at least for state and local folks, tells you that they're probably doing a pretty good job (even with the goofy restrictions like "you must buy from the lowest bidder even if their work is shit").
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by bragh on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:24AM
(#14340239)
Is it actually the law though, not just lazy officials? We had that problem in Estonia too, but some procurement officials have actually begun to write scoring systems for proposals and so being the lowest bidder is sometimes actually negatively scored.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:12AM
(#14339108)
You just stated that state and local government, by law, must go to the lowest bidder and that shoots them in the foot because there's cost over-runs, etc. That doesn't sound "pretty lean" or "accountable" to me.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by glangdale on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:27AM
(#14339155)
I am actually most sympathetic to the idea that the military is the single really identifiable point where large-scale waste is identifiable. However, even that spending is dwarfed by health and welfare transfer payments, and procurement is a fraction of military spending. So... yeah, procurement is big and wasteful. But in 2013 (the last year that Wikipedia had) we've got around ~100B of procurement out of 610B of military spending and out of 3.45 trillion dollars of spending.
That's like 1 dollar out of 34, probably not all 100% wasted either.
I'm not going to argue that there's not a lot of wasteful government spending - transfer payments that don't need to happen, waste in healthcare, etc. I just don't see much of a path towards a really substantial change in tax rates that would emerge from 'cutting waste'. Tackling transfer payments IMO is a much bigger deal, but this is also likely unfixable for political reasons (essentially the middle class have to be bribed to support anti-poverty programs by including them in the transfer payment merry-go-round).
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:35AM
(#14339184)
Military spending serves two purposes. The first is as a jobs program for the poor and nominally educated. The second is a sieve through which we pour ginormous sums of money in the hopes of creating technological breakthroughs such as computers, solar panels, nuclear power, etc. None of which would've come to market nearly as quickly, if at all, without seemingly insurmountable government waste. The United States wouldn't even have been conquered by Europeans without massive government waste shipping some people across the Atlantic.
It's important to keep these ideas in mind when we talk about government waste.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Clubber on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:37AM
(#14341419)
Also, military spending of WWII got us out of the depression. We haven't really stopped and no one really knows what would happen to our economy if we did.
I would like to see some of that diverted into more important things like health care. Of course the whole prison concept is very, very expensive. We house more prisoners (total, not per capita) than any other country in the world. How much does that cost us in money and liberty?
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @10:19PM
(#14355095)
Our military spending isn't as high as some would like you to think. They always show that stat that says we spend more than the top X other countries in the world combined. That's certainly a damning statistic. But if you look at our military spending as a percentage of GDP we're not even in the top 10. And it's important to note when comparing our spending to other first world countries, other countries get their defense spending subsidized by being our ally. They can spend less because we have their backs. If they had to proportionally provide for their own defenses, we'd look even more reasonable. Believe me, I think we could cut a LOT of military spending, it's just not as crazy out of whack as popular rhetoric would have you believe.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by ericras on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:15AM
(#14339118)
Easy to identify but widespread and hard to cure - one example is the practice of "needing" to exhaust this year's budget for fear of a reduction next year. In business you'd be rewarded for saving money. In government you replace an office full of Dell PCs that are less than a year old. This sort of inertia touches nearly every part of gov.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Clubber on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:40AM
(#14341452)
Yes, the idea that business is any better at not wasting money is a fallacy, particularly large, cash-cow businesses.
But your point is right. The incentives for budgeting, at least at the government institution I worked for years ago is if you don't use it, you lose it, so it leads to completely using the budget every year regardless of if it is actually needed or not.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by sundvor on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:21PM
(#14338467)
From someone of a Norwegian/Australian background, what the whole article describes is simply alien. People just aren't that selfish on a grand scale in either of my home countries.
Clearly, none of the non-voters ever read Matilda. Or understand that ultimately, the lack of public services will put everyone back.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by oceanghost on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:48PM
(#14338589)
As a Norweigan, you may not be in possession of certain facts about the US politics.
1. Almost all media in the US is severely biased.
2. This to me at least looks like something called the "national parks strategy." This is when the government funds its unpopular pet projects (frequently theft), and underfunds popular programs such as national parks, roads and the like then threatens the public with their closure if they do not pass tax increases. Frequently, if the tax is passed, they do a show project and misallocate the rest of the money. Over the time citizens have become wise and vote--entirely rationally-- for the safest option which is, no new taxes.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Sanddancer on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:10PM
(#14338680)
The media isn't biased as much as you think. It's anti-confrontational, which means stories about things people are upset about often get minified. However, the Washington Times, which you linked to, is fantastically biased. It's owned by the Unification Church, and has been repeatedly criticized for its pro-Moon stance. If you want to know what's really happening, don't read the washington times.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by throwaway7312 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:30PM
(#14338757)
US media is biased. Try this experiment: find a conservative friend and a liberal friend. Ask each of these friends which of the two papers in the parent and OP is more biased and which is more fact-based.
Your conservative friend will tell you the Washington Times is more fact-based and the New York Times is heavily biased. Your liberal friend will tell you the New York Times is more fact-based and the Washington Times is heavily biased.
Your first conclusion might be that one of your friends (whichever one whose beliefs oppose yours more) is insane or uneducated on what you know is true.
The more likely conclusion, however, is that each of these papers weaves heavy amounts of opinion, spin, and perspective on the "facts" it conveys, and that opinion and spin is invisible to those who share the same biases, while being conspicuous and grating to those who do not.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by oceanghost on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:15PM
(#14338701)
Well, this only proves my point I suppose. I did not know that-- but amnusingly... I live in Orange County, and believe me the recall is real and it is going to happen.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Lazare on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:01PM
(#14338636)
There's another point you're missing: The American government is incredibly poorly run.
People would probably be much more supportive of paying for government services if they were getting the level of quality and efficiency Norwegian taxpayers get. :)
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by merpnderp on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:18PM
(#14338715)
If it weren't for the train wreck that is the VA, and the problems with medicare/medicaid, a lot more people might be in favor of single payer/government health care. But if the government can't correct the VA problems after years of effort and billions in extra funding, how can the government suddenly fix the same problem only 100x larger?
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Lazare on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:42PM
(#14345397)
Yep. A fairly large chunk of the US would quite love to have, eg, the British NHS. Nobody wants to have the VA.
Moving from the US to another country it's amazing how well-liked government institutions are, even including the local equivalent of the IRS. And with good reason; they're well run too. In the US, the DMV is a punchline and a staple of standup comedy; a shorthand for the towering, malevolent incompetence of government, but most parts of government would work just as well. You could go years without a positive interaction with the government.
It was quite an interesting surprise to learn there are parts of the world where the government functions well and an interaction with them is not to be dreaded.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by sundvor on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:46PM
(#14338804)
I define something that is public as being available to use regardless of your standing.
If you have e.g. public health system, and public education, at high standards, your chance of success is to a vastly greater degree decoupled from the wealth of your family, or the suburb you live in.
The benefit is that society as a whole gets richer, you reduce crime, etc etc. Basically what comes around goes around.
To be opposed to having great public benefits e.g. just because you are from a family of great wealth and are unwilling to share some of that for the greater good is thus something I ultimately define as selfish. I also think it is short sighted, as no matter how well off you are the higher the chances you'll be affected by things like crime.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by mirimir on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:43PM
(#14338794)
Maybe "selfish" isn't quite right. More like self-interested. Or not community-minded. I'm guessing that those opposed to public services would prefer private services. So perhaps a subscription-based library system. With free services for the poor, funded by donations. But would that provide as much social benefit as a public service? I tend to doubt it.
Maybe libraries are a moot point, given the Internet. But the same issues come up for schools, police, fire, roads, bridges, etc. I mean, I have no children, so paying for schools seems like a rip-off sometimes. But on the other hand, I like living in a society that's at least somewhat literate.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Consultant32452 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @11:55PM
(#14339047)
Ignore the title, because the questioner is not Bernie Sanders. But this Milton Friedman response to this very question answers your question pretty succinctly.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by anigbrowl on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:01PM
(#14338635)
For perspective, some parts of Oregon are populated by people who moved there from the Old South because they wanted to live somewhere whiter and more conservative, so there are pockets of very strong ideological opposition to any sort of public institutions.
As a fellow Euro I really recommend the book American Nations by Colin Woodard (actually also from Oregon) if you want to understand the strange contradictions of US politics. One of the best history books I've read.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by hoodoof on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:45PM
(#14338569)
I think taxes are good. I don't mind paying taxes at all.
I want to support community services and public works and social equality.
The only context in which I really really hate paying tax is where I feel that the politicians are looting the public money to enrich themselves and give themselves generous employment benefits well beyond that of ordinary citizens.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by prostoalex on Sunday May 14, 2017 @11:50PM
(#14339025)
It's more complex than politicians looting for personal enrichment, and it feels like those corruption cases are handled with an occasional FBI arrest here and there.
Ever notice how some of the political candidates are supported by some public employee unions, e.g. a candidate supported (and frequently financed) by police, teachers, prison guards, etc.?
Well, that same politician, once elected, is frequently in charge of negotiating the public sector compensation and pension benefits. In what might come as a total surprise, they turn out to have very weak negotiating skills when it comes to dealing with unions that invested in their previous rounds.
You don't have to look very far - as far as few years ago the city of San Jose had to suspend hiring policemen, and lay off some junior teachers due to funding issues. Meanwhile on the other end of the paycheck spectrum a bunch of public employees were throwing early retirement parties, having locked in a six-figure pension for the rest of their lives http://www.mercurynews.com/2012/08/30/bay-areas-200k-club-an...
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Clubber on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:45AM
(#14341496)
A good example of this is all the union busting the GOP were championing in the 2010s or so. The police and fire unions supported the GOP and the GOP went on to reduce some of the power of the worker's unions. Scott Walker is one of these politicians. The police and fire unions were left unharmed and are still strong.
There could be an argument that the strength of the police unions are partially to blame with the issues we are having with police shootings and lack of prosecution, among other things.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by rrggrr on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:16PM
(#14338709)
“Only a crisis - actual or perceived - produces real change."
- Milton Friedman
Age 45 and up comprises the smallest number of HN readers, the largest number of Americans, the largest quantity of American voters, and the greatest concentration of wealth in America. This, majority demographic will support real change when there is no other option, but not before then. Most refuse to admit their generations enacted public policies that have left most cites States and the Federal Government irreversibly in debt.
Milton Friedman also said, "When that crisis occurs, the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around." Its critical that today's emerging leaders are well educated on what makes for sustainable economic and social policy, and what is required to dig ourselves out from the hole dug for us.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by danjayh on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:46PM
(#14338805)
Much of the problem lies with future unfunded obligations in Social Security. When Social Security was enacted, the average life expectancy was 61 and the full retirement age was 65 - the average person died before getting a dime. This is no longer the case, and it's why the program is going bankrupt. I, at 35 years of age, am not planning to ever receive social security & am saving at a rate that reflects that (slightly over Dave Ramsey's recommended 15%). I will vote ASAP to raise the full retirement age to 84, which is 4 years after the national average life expectancy of 79. Doing this will fill in a significant portion of the hole that prior generations have dug.
I would also support raising the retirement age for women to a higher value than that for men, due to the difference in life expectancy. Equal opportunity to collect, and all (ducks head to dodge flying objects). OK, maybe I'm half kidding about that, but dead serious about everything else.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by brohoolio on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:38PM
(#14338537)
In rural areas this seems like it will kill jobs and make the area less desirable.
There always is a balance to strike, not providing too many services at too high a cost, but killing off a library? Not being able to have police?
How is someone supposed to apply for a job if they don't have internet? How are they supposed to pull themselves up by their bootstraps? The library provides ways for people to get ahead.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by slackingoff2017 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:59PM
(#14338627)
Realistically every person in America can get enough money for a phone with internet access. An older used Android phone can be had for around $50. Internet is free in enough places that a phone with charger is sufficient.
A common and incorrect view of the homeless persists in America, to their peril. Destitute starving people exist in some countries but not those as rich as the US.
In the US and other wealthy countries basically 100% of chronic homeless are in that position due to drugs or mental illness. A normal person thrown on the street with nothing would be able to scrape together some semblance of a normal life within a few months.
This is hurting the homeless in the US greatly. The common view of homelessness as someone just "down on their luck" leads to bad attempts at solutions. Mentally stable adults without drug problems do not stay homeless in the US and rarely become homeless.
To help the homeless we need vastly increased spending on mental health and addiction treatment for the poor. We also need socialized housing for those too mentally I'll to ever hold a job. A lot of homeless people will be homeless unless someone pays for a place for them to live indefinitely.
It's surprising that the closing of some library branches is somehow the fault of overly paranoid tax-haters rather than out-of-control spending patterns.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by ojbyrne on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:02PM
(#14338640)
"More money in voters’ wallets from tax cuts in Washington could reduce the sting in asking people to pay more at home, or it could just reinforce the idea that all taxes are meant to go down."
The latest tax plan that was floated means very few people in states like Oregon (with high state taxes) are going to see any reduction, because they're going to make those state taxes non-deductible. Not sure how that plays into this argument.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by scarface74 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:25PM
(#14338736)
State taxes already aren't tax deductible for the middle class. The standard deduction for a married couple is $12000. If you have a mortgage on average price house* ($185,000), you're not clearing enough in mortgage interest and state taxes to make itemizing worthwhile.
I know there are other deductions, but I still doubt that the average middle income household ($60,000/year) is clearing over $12,000 in deductions.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by maxharris on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:45PM
(#14338570)
I live a block away from a public library. It's so close that I can see it right outside my window!
And you know what? I have not been to that library ever, and I've lived in this neighborhood for years.
Even if you happen to use your library every day now, you probably won't be doing that in twenty years, regardless of whether or not they continue to offer service in your town.
Taking a wide view, what else should we expect, now that we have computers in our pockets connected to a far larger and more comprehensive source of knowledge?
There are a lot of details and small objections to my point here, to be sure, but the technology that's driving this trend is NOT going away.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by felipemnoa on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:53PM
(#14338607)
I go to the library almost daily. Plenty of people there. More so than before the internet. A big chunk of them go to use the computers there, study, read the newspaper, or just to socialize a bit. A lot of them are there for other activities: story time for children, yoga, computer classes, movie time. It seems to me that libraries are turning into community centers, which is great. Every community needs a library that doubles as a quasi community center.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by Steuard on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:24PM
(#14338734)
My librarian friends talk a lot these days about the changing roles that libraries play in their communities. There are certainly a lot of people who have less need for them purely as a place to borrow books and look up reference materials. But that's not all that libraries are, and for those and other services libraries are particularly valuable to people who aren't so fortunate.
I'm not even just talking about the range of community events that libraries often host: my kindergarten-aged daughter has enjoyed going to our local library for weekend read-along events for years, for instance, and I've hosted a local science outreach event there, and they're the location for a local arts festival every fall, and they're a natural space for a variety of community meetings. Some libraries even run their own maker spaces.
But it can be easy for highly educated and/or reasonably well-off people to forget how much of a lifeline a library can be. A lot of librarians I know talk about how library computer services are the only way for some of the poorer people in their communities to hunt for jobs, for example, because they don't have reliable internet access at home. (That's getting better as more and more people do have computers in their pockets, but there's a long way to go.) Kids growing up in families that are struggling financially don't have shelves and shelves of books to learn from at home: a library can do wonders to fill that gap if the family makes a habit of it. And librarians themselves can do wonders to help people sort through the oceans of available information to find the most useful and trustworthy sources: that's their specialized expertise, and it's not becoming less important as we gain increasing access to far larger and more comprehensive sources. Their training can be useful to anyone, but it's especially helpful to be able to turn to a librarian if (e.g.) you haven't gone through a high quality college program that's taught you the basics of that expertise yourself.
There's a lot more to say, and yes, libraries are going to need to transform in fascinating ways in the future. But there really does seem to be a role for something akin to libraries in our society. (And, as an aside, you'll rarely find a group of people more fervently dedicated to issues like privacy and freedom of information than librarians. That's valuable, too.)
> Closing libraries is inevitable, the argument goes, in an era when two out of three British homes have a computer. But that is far from the whole story. While 200 million books are sold every year, more than 310 million are borrowed. The one-in-three homes without a computer are those of the nation's poorer children, many of whom live without even a table at which they can do their homework.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by gene-h on Sunday May 14, 2017 @09:58PM
(#14338625)
You should probably visit your local library. My local library runs a makerspace, where people can check out equipment, arduinos, and use 3d printers. In addition, our local library cards allow us to bypass paywalls for news sites, scientific journals, and check out e-books online without having the physically visit the library.
I would really like to see paywalls go away within twenty years, but I am doubtful that this will happen.
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by maxharris on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:03PM
(#14338652)
I see I have three comments here, and I'll just state my main objection to all three of you (felipemnoa, gene-h, anigbrowl):
Ok, so when are the libraries/community centers going to turn those awful fluorescent lights off, bring in some comfortable couches and start serving alcohol and coffee?
Because if they don't start doing that, there's just no draw for me...
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by rosser on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:40PM
(#14338788)
If it doesn't serve use-cases you're interested in, it shouldn't exist?
EDIT: On the other hand, is leasing out space to a commercial coffee stand a revenue stream that libraries — particularly smaller, less well-funded ones — might consider?
Re:Where Anti-Tax Fervor Means ‘All Services Will Cease’
by felipemnoa on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:14PM
(#14338696)
Might as well just go and sit at a bar with a computer. The library I go to you can at least bring your own coffee or any other liquids, except probably alcohol :)
Unfortunately, as we've seen from Republican-led governments operating under this Grover Norquist-esque model for thirty years, the beast never starves. In Washington DC they print money to offset deficits. Instead of cutting waste, the libraries and the parks are closed.
There's still a great desire out there for responsible government that can operate efficiently. That can keep the libraries open by trimming bureaucratic waste rather than asking for more money. Probably will always be a pipe dream.
Waste that you get from the privatization efforts are an order of magnitude more expensive. Unfortunately, the people in policy positions today are clueless... voting no doesn't fix anything.
I understand the drive to make government more efficient, run better, but I'm not sure if that's the goal of the current conservative movement. At least here in Michigan the state government under republican control has caused all sorts of issues, like the Flint water crisis.
For what it's worth, I'm all for reigning in government spending and power. Sounds like we are ratcheting up another drug war.
The best way I've seen it done is to just slash everything by the same amount. Sadly this results in things like closing libraries.
Nobody agrees on what's waste and what isn't. If everyone agreed that X was a big waste of money it wouldn't exist, so we're stuck with a system where every dollar goes to a thing somebody cares about
On top of that, a lot of times like in the case of the library, you know exactly where the tax increases are going.
This piece does a fairly good job of presenting the conservative point of view: that there are mountains of waste in government to cut rather than hike taxes. I agree with that perspective.
And it was that agreement with conservatism as a political philosophy that I asked to explore. It's not that your opinion is invalid, but that it is unresponsive to the question that was asked. I am not interested in having an argument with you, I'm interested in knowing where that other person was coming from.
Beyond that there's huge obvious ones that come along all the time like the F22s we keep buying more of even though the military doesn't want them. This of course is a jobs program for engineers and a way to again funnel money into the districts which all these random parts are procured.
"Instead of actually going with the lowest bidder .. " In many states, it's law that they must go with the lowest bidder. This often causes problems because that lowest bidder delivers shoddy work that leads to eventual cost overruns--going with the "best value" instead of "lowest price" would reward companies that could meet both cost AND quality expectations. It'd also more closely reflect private sector considerations if those laws were changed; a private company can spend more for higher quality and get the long-term benefit of that quality deliverable, and that's a trade-off and decision that's simply taken away from state/local procurement professionals.
State and local procurement tends to run pretty lean, and tends to be pretty accountable. All this stuff is public record, and local papers will often cull through that stuff looking for juicy nuggets. The relative rarity of public purchasing scandals, at least for state and local folks, tells you that they're probably doing a pretty good job (even with the goofy restrictions like "you must buy from the lowest bidder even if their work is shit").
That's like 1 dollar out of 34, probably not all 100% wasted either.
I'm not going to argue that there's not a lot of wasteful government spending - transfer payments that don't need to happen, waste in healthcare, etc. I just don't see much of a path towards a really substantial change in tax rates that would emerge from 'cutting waste'. Tackling transfer payments IMO is a much bigger deal, but this is also likely unfixable for political reasons (essentially the middle class have to be bribed to support anti-poverty programs by including them in the transfer payment merry-go-round).
It's important to keep these ideas in mind when we talk about government waste.
I would like to see some of that diverted into more important things like health care. Of course the whole prison concept is very, very expensive. We house more prisoners (total, not per capita) than any other country in the world. How much does that cost us in money and liberty?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi/uk/06/prisons/html/nn2...
But your point is right. The incentives for budgeting, at least at the government institution I worked for years ago is if you don't use it, you lose it, so it leads to completely using the budget every year regardless of if it is actually needed or not.
You're only getting a cost savings medal if it's substantial and doesn't affect your own department.
Clearly, none of the non-voters ever read Matilda. Or understand that ultimately, the lack of public services will put everyone back.
1. Almost all media in the US is severely biased.
2. This to me at least looks like something called the "national parks strategy." This is when the government funds its unpopular pet projects (frequently theft), and underfunds popular programs such as national parks, roads and the like then threatens the public with their closure if they do not pass tax increases. Frequently, if the tax is passed, they do a show project and misallocate the rest of the money. Over the time citizens have become wise and vote--entirely rationally-- for the safest option which is, no new taxes.
California is in the midst of such a battle now: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/may/11/californians...
Your conservative friend will tell you the Washington Times is more fact-based and the New York Times is heavily biased. Your liberal friend will tell you the New York Times is more fact-based and the Washington Times is heavily biased.
Your first conclusion might be that one of your friends (whichever one whose beliefs oppose yours more) is insane or uneducated on what you know is true.
The more likely conclusion, however, is that each of these papers weaves heavy amounts of opinion, spin, and perspective on the "facts" it conveys, and that opinion and spin is invisible to those who share the same biases, while being conspicuous and grating to those who do not.
a. well below the rate of inflation
and
b. not enraging people.
Ultimately, things like this are probably for the better.
People would probably be much more supportive of paying for government services if they were getting the level of quality and efficiency Norwegian taxpayers get. :)
Moving from the US to another country it's amazing how well-liked government institutions are, even including the local equivalent of the IRS. And with good reason; they're well run too. In the US, the DMV is a punchline and a staple of standup comedy; a shorthand for the towering, malevolent incompetence of government, but most parts of government would work just as well. You could go years without a positive interaction with the government.
It was quite an interesting surprise to learn there are parts of the world where the government functions well and an interaction with them is not to be dreaded.
I was surprised to hear you describe people voting against continued public service as 'selfish'. Why would you consider them selfish?
If you have e.g. public health system, and public education, at high standards, your chance of success is to a vastly greater degree decoupled from the wealth of your family, or the suburb you live in.
The benefit is that society as a whole gets richer, you reduce crime, etc etc. Basically what comes around goes around.
To be opposed to having great public benefits e.g. just because you are from a family of great wealth and are unwilling to share some of that for the greater good is thus something I ultimately define as selfish. I also think it is short sighted, as no matter how well off you are the higher the chances you'll be affected by things like crime.
Hopefully this explains my thinking.
Maybe libraries are a moot point, given the Internet. But the same issues come up for schools, police, fire, roads, bridges, etc. I mean, I have no children, so paying for schools seems like a rip-off sometimes. But on the other hand, I like living in a society that's at least somewhat literate.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sElz_P6QsZo
As a fellow Euro I really recommend the book American Nations by Colin Woodard (actually also from Oregon) if you want to understand the strange contradictions of US politics. One of the best history books I've read.
I want to support community services and public works and social equality.
The only context in which I really really hate paying tax is where I feel that the politicians are looting the public money to enrich themselves and give themselves generous employment benefits well beyond that of ordinary citizens.
Ever notice how some of the political candidates are supported by some public employee unions, e.g. a candidate supported (and frequently financed) by police, teachers, prison guards, etc.?
Well, that same politician, once elected, is frequently in charge of negotiating the public sector compensation and pension benefits. In what might come as a total surprise, they turn out to have very weak negotiating skills when it comes to dealing with unions that invested in their previous rounds.
You don't have to look very far - as far as few years ago the city of San Jose had to suspend hiring policemen, and lay off some junior teachers due to funding issues. Meanwhile on the other end of the paycheck spectrum a bunch of public employees were throwing early retirement parties, having locked in a six-figure pension for the rest of their lives http://www.mercurynews.com/2012/08/30/bay-areas-200k-club-an...
There could be an argument that the strength of the police unions are partially to blame with the issues we are having with police shootings and lack of prosecution, among other things.
Age 45 and up comprises the smallest number of HN readers, the largest number of Americans, the largest quantity of American voters, and the greatest concentration of wealth in America. This, majority demographic will support real change when there is no other option, but not before then. Most refuse to admit their generations enacted public policies that have left most cites States and the Federal Government irreversibly in debt.
Milton Friedman also said, "When that crisis occurs, the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around." Its critical that today's emerging leaders are well educated on what makes for sustainable economic and social policy, and what is required to dig ourselves out from the hole dug for us.
I would also support raising the retirement age for women to a higher value than that for men, due to the difference in life expectancy. Equal opportunity to collect, and all (ducks head to dodge flying objects). OK, maybe I'm half kidding about that, but dead serious about everything else.
There always is a balance to strike, not providing too many services at too high a cost, but killing off a library? Not being able to have police?
How is someone supposed to apply for a job if they don't have internet? How are they supposed to pull themselves up by their bootstraps? The library provides ways for people to get ahead.
A common and incorrect view of the homeless persists in America, to their peril. Destitute starving people exist in some countries but not those as rich as the US.
In the US and other wealthy countries basically 100% of chronic homeless are in that position due to drugs or mental illness. A normal person thrown on the street with nothing would be able to scrape together some semblance of a normal life within a few months.
This is hurting the homeless in the US greatly. The common view of homelessness as someone just "down on their luck" leads to bad attempts at solutions. Mentally stable adults without drug problems do not stay homeless in the US and rarely become homeless.
To help the homeless we need vastly increased spending on mental health and addiction treatment for the poor. We also need socialized housing for those too mentally I'll to ever hold a job. A lot of homeless people will be homeless unless someone pays for a place for them to live indefinitely.
http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/spending_chart_1900_2020...
It's surprising that the closing of some library branches is somehow the fault of overly paranoid tax-haters rather than out-of-control spending patterns.
The latest tax plan that was floated means very few people in states like Oregon (with high state taxes) are going to see any reduction, because they're going to make those state taxes non-deductible. Not sure how that plays into this argument.
I know there are other deductions, but I still doubt that the average middle income household ($60,000/year) is clearing over $12,000 in deductions.
http://www.deptofnumbers.com/income/us/
http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/4957604
And you know what? I have not been to that library ever, and I've lived in this neighborhood for years.
Even if you happen to use your library every day now, you probably won't be doing that in twenty years, regardless of whether or not they continue to offer service in your town.
Taking a wide view, what else should we expect, now that we have computers in our pockets connected to a far larger and more comprehensive source of knowledge?
There are a lot of details and small objections to my point here, to be sure, but the technology that's driving this trend is NOT going away.
I'm not even just talking about the range of community events that libraries often host: my kindergarten-aged daughter has enjoyed going to our local library for weekend read-along events for years, for instance, and I've hosted a local science outreach event there, and they're the location for a local arts festival every fall, and they're a natural space for a variety of community meetings. Some libraries even run their own maker spaces.
But it can be easy for highly educated and/or reasonably well-off people to forget how much of a lifeline a library can be. A lot of librarians I know talk about how library computer services are the only way for some of the poorer people in their communities to hunt for jobs, for example, because they don't have reliable internet access at home. (That's getting better as more and more people do have computers in their pockets, but there's a long way to go.) Kids growing up in families that are struggling financially don't have shelves and shelves of books to learn from at home: a library can do wonders to fill that gap if the family makes a habit of it. And librarians themselves can do wonders to help people sort through the oceans of available information to find the most useful and trustworthy sources: that's their specialized expertise, and it's not becoming less important as we gain increasing access to far larger and more comprehensive sources. Their training can be useful to anyone, but it's especially helpful to be able to turn to a librarian if (e.g.) you haven't gone through a high quality college program that's taught you the basics of that expertise yourself.
There's a lot more to say, and yes, libraries are going to need to transform in fascinating ways in the future. But there really does seem to be a role for something akin to libraries in our society. (And, as an aside, you'll rarely find a group of people more fervently dedicated to issues like privacy and freedom of information than librarians. That's valuable, too.)
http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/editorials/leading-artic...
> Closing libraries is inevitable, the argument goes, in an era when two out of three British homes have a computer. But that is far from the whole story. While 200 million books are sold every year, more than 310 million are borrowed. The one-in-three homes without a computer are those of the nation's poorer children, many of whom live without even a table at which they can do their homework.
And what if we had nice narrow European-style streets, free of cars, connecting these places together? That would be even more amazing.
This is the "I don't have a use for it, so no-one else possibly could either" mentality.
I would really like to see paywalls go away within twenty years, but I am doubtful that this will happen.
Ok, so when are the libraries/community centers going to turn those awful fluorescent lights off, bring in some comfortable couches and start serving alcohol and coffee?
Because if they don't start doing that, there's just no draw for me...
EDIT: On the other hand, is leasing out space to a commercial coffee stand a revenue stream that libraries — particularly smaller, less well-funded ones — might consider?