That's really not true. The microwaves in this case are being used to communicate between NYC and Chicago to trade products in increments of <1bp. Retail investors may not be as concerned about such fluctuations, but "actual market participants" most certainly do.
> Same thing for time, you don't care that you send the order at 15:14:25.0000001 or 15:14:25.5
Again, this is not true. If Fed decides to adjust interest rates at FOMC (14:00:00), they likely do so in a 25bp increment. Market makers absolutely care whether the order is received at the matching engine at 14:00:00.01 vs 14:00:00.5, as such a move can cause large fluctuations in a portfolio's value.
> Markets should be tailored to the needs of its users.
Agreed. Market makers need to be able to adjust their pricing to reflect market conditions. This is critical to the price discovery process. Were they prohibited from updating their pricing rapidly, they would either cease providing liquidity entirely or show much wider spreads to reflect their increased levels of risk. Clearly such an outcome is not advantageous to the market.
Well, they are. HFTs do 70% of the volume, so the markets are tailored to their needs.
1. Of course it's arbitrary. And the current time resolution (a computer tick = one ten-millionth?) is just as arbitrary.
2. The market is a man-made system, it's made by and for humans. It would make sense that the time resolution of events is mapped to human perception: You need subsecond liquidity because traders want to perceive their orders as being immediate. But as soon as the order looks immediate, you don't need further precision. The additional resolution is useless to anyone making decisions and only encourages a stupid race that requires immense investments.
3. Can you explain what you think is the value in submillisecond trading?
So why should we change it?
> The market is a man-made system, it's made by and for humans. It would make sense that the time resolution of events is mapped to human perception: You need subsecond liquidity because traders want to perceive their orders as being immediate. But as soon as the order looks immediate, you don't need further precision. The additional resolution is useless to anyone making decisions and only encourages a stupid race that requires immense investments.
I don't follow - by that logic, everything created by humans shouldn't have resolution greater than what we can perceive. Does this hold for, say, HTTP requests, or pings?
> Can you explain what you think is the value in submillisecond trading?
It allows me to complete trades before the market turns against me. In the absence of any particular harm, faster execution is better.
Also, to your third point -- as a market maker, more information is strictly better than less information (as a corollary, shorter time resolution is better than longer time resolution). Any time I have less information, my predictions are worse, my risk goes up, and I have to either quote less or wider, making liquidity worse and hurting other (non-HFT) participants.
Who are the "actual market participants"? Why do you believe they don't care about sub-penny differences, or sub-second differences?
When you buy a stock from your banker, you don't care that you buy it at 65 or 65.00001.
Same thing for time, you don't care that you send the order at 15:14:25.0000001 or 15:14:25.5
Markets should be tailored to the needs of its users.