Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by philelly on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @01:16PM
(#1433263)
it's ironic that a blog post like this would use an image that appears to be poking fun at the fervor with which people record and analyze paul graham's teachings
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by Groxx on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @05:08PM
(#1433891)
75. The pointy-haired boss miraculous combines two qualities that are common by themselves, but rarely seen together: (a) he knows nothing whatsoever about technology, and (b) he has very strong opinions about it.
Not in my experience. In general, people who know the least are the most vocal.
I'm about 90% in agreement with the thoughts as a whole. There are some statements I find patently false / seen through rose-tinted glasses, like 48:
I think there are three reasons we treat making money as different: the misleading model of wealth we learn as children; the disreputable way in which, till recently, most fortunes were accumulated, and the worry that great variations in income are somehow bad for society. As far as I can tell, the first is mistake, the second outdated, and the third empirically false.
In what way is money accumulation today different than the past? Another quote cites that spammers spam because their cost is nothing, but it incurs a cost of ~5 man-weeks per million emails on those they spam. Isn't that a perfect example of accumulating money in a "disreputable way"? And how about all the recent exposures of questionable banking practices? And pork-barrel legislation? Bribery? Monopolistic practices?
Money-making today is no cleaner than yesterday. Just because you (pg / anyone believing this) may accumulate money and use it ethically does not imply others do the same.
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by kiba on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @06:18PM
(#1434036)
Money-making today is no cleaner than yesterday. Just because you (pg / anyone believing this) may accumulate money and use it ethically does not imply others do the same.
Modern civilization and its achievement is certainly not the result of lazy bureaucracy accumulating money on the back of hardworking pleasant. It's certainly a result of some amount of "rules of law".
For prosperity to be widespread, you need incentive to accumulate capitals, build stuff that people actually want to buy, etc.
The world is pretty fair. Just that humans can be too unfair and short-sighted.(Like caring more about relative status instead of total wealth)
Poor nations just have more corrupt bureaucracy, unethical businessmen, and lawlessness than wealthy nations.
Yes, the bureaucracy in American and Europe aren't certainly helping matters, but relatively speaking, they're still less corrupt than what you would find in third world countries.
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by Groxx on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @07:37PM
(#1434198)
This rebuts my claim that there's still widespread unethical gains how? You just stated that the majority of Earth's population is more corrupt than America / Europe.
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by BrandonM on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @09:37PM
(#1434434)
He is trying to say that accumulation of money is not automatically bad just because some people attempt to do it in an unethical, nonproductive fashion. As long as the attempt to become wealthy is also accompanied by basic morals and decency, the pursuit of wealth is a noble venture.
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by sprout on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @11:54PM
(#1434648)
Well, I think there are more fortunes being made in an ethical manner than there used to be, this much is true.
But where I think the real losses to society come from are inheritance, and what you might call the "soft inheritance" that comes from being born in a given class. The problem with earning a lot of income is that your children are assumed to be equally good with that income, and society hands it to them without a second thought, regardless of their individual merits. Compounded over generations the effect is truly terrible.
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by endlessvoid94 on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @01:02PM
(#1433233)
I think taking his essays and making them bullet points loses quite a bit of the enjoyment. He gives examples with some prose in his essays that just drive the points further home.
Plus, lists of things suck.
EDIT: Does anyone else see the irony in the score of this comment?
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by Scott_MacGregor on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @03:33PM
(#1433618)
This might be fun, and it could generate a little more industry coverage (free advertising) for the book. Maybe there could be a small competition of some sorts within the forum to win 3 copies of the book.
It could involve something that is not coding, and that the forum members can judge (vote on). Like a best discussion topic / article submitted on Saturday the 26th between 9am and 2pm PST. All votes must be in by 7pm PST. Ten finalists could be selected, and the vote totals submitted to a separate random number generated for each one--highest 3 numbers win books. 1 entry per forum member who wants to participate.
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by BrandonM on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @03:17PM
(#1433579)
How much material can you pull from a book without getting into copyright issues? Is the post's author providing enough new ideas to warrant a "commentary" argument?
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by prewett on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @05:14PM
(#1433905)
Copyright doesn't protect ideas so much as the expression of them. There are also fair use provisions, which include the discussing the copyrighted material. A list is given at http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl102.html (there is a link to the whole law, use the Chapter 1 link). Judging by those factors, he was clearly summarizing, it was for non-profit use, he did not appear to be quoting directly, and even if he was, the quotes comprise a very small part of the whole work, and the summary does not diminish the value of the original work, I would say he is on very safe legal grounds. (IANAL, though)
Re:Powerful Thoughts from Paul Graham (Notes from Hackers an...
by BrandonM on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @09:33PM
(#1434429)
Thanks. Yeah, I wasn't trying to accuse him of anything... He is obviously providing value while also indirectly encouraging people to read the book. Besides, pg had posted in this submission before I did without having a negative attitude toward the article.
I was mainly curious just how much is allowed. In a time when multimedia companies claim copyright infringement left and right, it's interesting to note the difference between print and audio/video copyrighted materials.
http://media.photobucket.com/image/last%20supper/thecathoder...
Not in my experience. In general, people who know the least are the most vocal.
I'm about 90% in agreement with the thoughts as a whole. There are some statements I find patently false / seen through rose-tinted glasses, like 48:
I think there are three reasons we treat making money as different: the misleading model of wealth we learn as children; the disreputable way in which, till recently, most fortunes were accumulated, and the worry that great variations in income are somehow bad for society. As far as I can tell, the first is mistake, the second outdated, and the third empirically false.
In what way is money accumulation today different than the past? Another quote cites that spammers spam because their cost is nothing, but it incurs a cost of ~5 man-weeks per million emails on those they spam. Isn't that a perfect example of accumulating money in a "disreputable way"? And how about all the recent exposures of questionable banking practices? And pork-barrel legislation? Bribery? Monopolistic practices?
Money-making today is no cleaner than yesterday. Just because you (pg / anyone believing this) may accumulate money and use it ethically does not imply others do the same.
Modern civilization and its achievement is certainly not the result of lazy bureaucracy accumulating money on the back of hardworking pleasant. It's certainly a result of some amount of "rules of law".
For prosperity to be widespread, you need incentive to accumulate capitals, build stuff that people actually want to buy, etc.
The world is pretty fair. Just that humans can be too unfair and short-sighted.(Like caring more about relative status instead of total wealth)
Poor nations just have more corrupt bureaucracy, unethical businessmen, and lawlessness than wealthy nations.
Yes, the bureaucracy in American and Europe aren't certainly helping matters, but relatively speaking, they're still less corrupt than what you would find in third world countries.
But where I think the real losses to society come from are inheritance, and what you might call the "soft inheritance" that comes from being born in a given class. The problem with earning a lot of income is that your children are assumed to be equally good with that income, and society hands it to them without a second thought, regardless of their individual merits. Compounded over generations the effect is truly terrible.
We've done some to stem the tide, but not enough.
Plus, lists of things suck.
EDIT: Does anyone else see the irony in the score of this comment?
Things that suck:
It could involve something that is not coding, and that the forum members can judge (vote on). Like a best discussion topic / article submitted on Saturday the 26th between 9am and 2pm PST. All votes must be in by 7pm PST. Ten finalists could be selected, and the vote totals submitted to a separate random number generated for each one--highest 3 numbers win books. 1 entry per forum member who wants to participate.
I was mainly curious just how much is allowed. In a time when multimedia companies claim copyright infringement left and right, it's interesting to note the difference between print and audio/video copyrighted materials.