News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by adventured on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:23AM (#14324149)
First of all, Walmart I'll note consistently pays one of the world's highest corporate income tax rates, at around 30%. Their income tax is about equal to what that article claims the subsidy is.

Ok, let's present the alternative then.

Walmart automates its massive retail operations substantially over the next 10-15 years, using robotics and AI.

Their goal is to match the dollar of sales to employee ratio of, say, beloved Costco. And or try to keep up with Amazon's ability to highly automate its operations (competitive pricing advantages etc).

There went one million jobs, consisting largely of employees with few skills and very limited alternative employment prospects.

Now what? Here's the reality when you remove the one-sided emotion-driven premise in the article: it's better to subsidize those employees to a modest extent, than to a 100% extent (which is the scenario coming for tax payers; the harder / more expensive you make it on Walmart to employ those people, the faster they're going to automate their jobs away).

Also, if you want to reduce the subsidy, raise the minimum wage (or the earned income tax credit, a vastly superior approach; which then begets a further debate on the subsidy), which Walmart has routinely supported. They support it because it harms their weaker competitors, whereas Walmart can deal with it. When you raise the minimum wage, Walmart will either optimize by firing workers / using automation further, or they'll push increased costs onto customers, which gets you right back to the same place in terms of tax payers paying for Walmart's employees (hint: every employed adult in America pays for their employees, they have $485 billion in sales).

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by gruturo on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:33AM (#14324243)
> Ok, let's present the alternative then.

>Walmart automates its massive retail operations substantially over the next 10-15 years, using robotics and AI.

You're presenting this as an alternative, but this is happening _anyway_ as soon as practically viable.

Underpaying workers simply moves this break-even point by some years, it doesn't change anything else and is not an alternative.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by mtberatwork on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:37AM (#14324277)
> the minimum wage ... which Walmart has routinely supported.

Do you have any links for further reading on this? From what I've read, they've only raised their min wage from $9 to $10 after protests by their work force. I certainly wouldn't call this support of raising the minimum wage (but perhaps they've since changed their tune?).

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by cpwright on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:42AM (#14324320)
The federal minimum wage is only $7.25. By paying $10, they are paying 38% more than the minimum. Even at 9 they are 24% above the minimum. I expect that they would prefer a minimum wage exactly equal to what they pay as a minimum, because that would disadvantage less efficient competitors.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by dragonwriter on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:46AM (#14324369)
> I expect that they would prefer a minimum wage exactly equal to what they pay as a minimum, because that would disadvantage less efficient competitors.

No, it would disadvantage competitors that could get by with labor with lower market value per unit of labor, which are not necessarily less efficient (if they were delivering the same output per unit of labor using less expensive labor, they'd be more efficient, for example, not less.)

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by brianbreslin on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:48AM (#14324383)
I would be more interested to see how each $.50 in hourly wage raises translates to improved efficiency, employee churn, and reduction in employee theft.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by j2bax on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:53AM (#14324444)
We could always give those low skilled workers shovels and pay them to dig holes and fill them back in. Oh wait, thats not okay either.