Re:A federal court has denied a pre-trial motion to dismiss ...
by emodendroket on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:25AM
(#14324177)
Well obviously their contention is that you're buying a license to use the software and not the software itself. You're free to disagree but it's internally consistent.
Re:A federal court has denied a pre-trial motion to dismiss ...
by sqeaky on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:51AM
(#14324418)
They can disagree all they want, but it is on them to prove that I agreed to buy a license, when I am physically holding something I bought. I didn't have to sign a contract for it. Adding terms after the purchase makes it a post-purchase agreement and that is unenforceable in most western jurisdictions.
Re:A federal court has denied a pre-trial motion to dismiss ...
by emodendroket on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:40AM
(#14324947)
Somebody should inform all the companies selling enterprise software whose entire model depends on selling seats, then.
Re:A federal court has denied a pre-trial motion to dismiss ...
by sqeaky on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:57AM
(#14325088)
Most of those have agreements at the time of purchase. Those are some of the most legitimate dealings in software sales.
Re:A federal court has denied a pre-trial motion to dismiss ...
by emodendroket on Friday May 12, 2017 @01:14PM
(#14325777)
Anyway, as I replied to the other guy, Venor v. Autodesk shows that some courts have upheld "shrinkwrap" licensing. I don't think it's a settled question in US law.
Re:A federal court has denied a pre-trial motion to dismiss ...
by rlpb on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:47AM
(#14325000)
That may be their contention, but this is exactly why this is fundamentally different to the copyleft case. The GPL requires none of this.
I would add that it seems pretty specious to argue that I bought a license when the license was not presented to me at the time I paid for the product and left the store, but I accept that this could be their contention.
Re:A federal court has denied a pre-trial motion to dismiss ...
by emodendroket on Friday May 12, 2017 @01:12PM
(#14325769)
Perhaps, but not without precedent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vernor_v._Autodesk,_Inc.
(note: the period is part of the URL)
Why not? If I own a chair, I have the right to use it. If I own a copy of the software (that I paid for in a store, for example), then there is nothing in law that says that I cannot use it. I have rights over what I own. Nothing restricts that.
Copyright law exists to protect software writers by providing them with a means to make money making software. This law restricts my ability to make copies. There is no law that restricts my ability to use what I own.